Henry IV, Part I Third lecture - University of California ...

Henry IV, Part I Third lecture - University of California ...

Henry IV, Part I Third lecture Depose me? Power and legitimacy Can Henry find legitimacy for his usurped kingship? So shaken as we are, so wan with care . . . How to legitimate his rule: his desire for new broils in a world that might sacralize his reign. Against the abomination, impiety of civil war (ll. 5-13). Instead a war to unite England in a sacred cause. BUT this our purpose . . .

And now new rebellion from Wales, Glendower. And new threats from Scots in North. And so he must neglect our holy purpose for Jerusalem. Ironies of the new rebellion The self-consuming nature of rebellion: Henrys old allies now challenge him. Worcesters gaff: I, 3, 12-13. He reminds Henry of his own rebellion. Henrys bind: Hotspurs refusal of prisoners, unless Henry ransoms Mortimer. But Mortimer may have as good a claim in the throne as Henry. Is Henry right about revolted Mortimer?

I, 3, 125ff: with Northumberland, Hotspur, Worcester in revolt, the pattern that Henry set in motion continues anew. How to rule in a world in which kingship has lost its sense of divine legitimacy? Henrys bind: He lacks the clear legitimacy Richard possessed. Rebelling, he has brought rebellion on himself. His eldest son seems not fit to inherit the kingdom. Because of rebellion, he cannot try to create legitimacy by a crusade to the

holy land. Instead of legitimate kingship, performative kingship Lacking legitimacy, Henry must perform his kingship. He acts the king with Worcester and Northumberland. But having a plausible heir apparent would help: His interview with Hal: III. 2. Is Hal in fact a punishment for his rebellion: ll 4-17. His own path: ll. 39ff. Opinion, that did help me to the crown opinion? This is a new understanding. He managed his appearances: seldom seen, he was wondered at And then I stole all courtesy from heaven . . . And made King Richard his foil.

Hal needs to perform his prospective kingship. Hotspur now giving a better performance of kingship: ll. 96ff. Hals alternative idea of a performance of heir-apparent Hell play the part of the reformed prodigal (soliloquy, I, 2, 188ff I know you all and will a while uphold/ The unyoked humor of your idleness). Now his vision of his reformation: III, 2, 132ff. Hotspur his factor, a servant to gather up glory. Hell seize Hotspurs honor and exchange it for his indignities. Or die.

All very neat? Tavern world as foil or mirror? Hal: Who,I rob? I a thief? (I, 2, 134) Falstaff: Theres neither honesty, manhood, nor good fellowship in thee, nor camst not of the blood royal if thou darest not stand for ten shillings. (Ten-shilling coin was a royal) Treachery of chamberlain in II, 1; he betrays his guests. Gadshill: I am joined with no foot landrakers . . . but with nobility and tranquility . . . And thieves robbing thieves in II.2. Falstaff as king, deposed by Hal: II, 4, 420. (Later, in H. IV, part 2, Hal will, without intending

it, depose his father, seizing the crown.) The rebellion: military realities and Hotspurs honor IV, 1, Hotspur the king of honor, but . . Northumberlands sickness doth infect/ The very lifeblood of our enterprise. And yet, in faith, it is not! Why? Hotspurs rhetorical turn, ll 76ff. H: O that Glendower were come. And Hotspurs response. His eagerness to fight: IV, 3. Archbishop of Yorks assessment: IV, 4, 19-20. Is there reason for the rebellion?

Henrys offer: IV, 3, 46ff. Hotspurs response: Henry owes us. A matter of honor? And Henrys title isnt good enough.

Falstaffs rejoinder to Worcesters protest, V, 1: Rebellion lay in his way and he found it. Worcesters reasons Henrys illegitimacy, ingratitude. Single combat between Hal and Hotspur? Fat chance! Reiteration of Henrys offer: 104ff. Not conveyed to Hotspur! Worcesters self-interest. So Hotspur and rebels are outnumbered 3 to 1 and still want to join battle. The king hath many marching in his coats V, 3: we learn Douglas has already killed Stafford disguised as king. Douglas now kills Blunt disguised as king. Audiences sense of this, and then our

realization. Douglas: Ill murder all his wardrobe. Honor? Men giving their lives for kings safety. Falstaffs comment on Blunts honor. I like not such grinning honor as Sir Walter hath. Give me life . . . Hals gallantry, or his gallant image? Vernons verbal image: IV, 1, 104. His praise of Hotspur and offer of single combat,V, 1, 83ff. V, 4: refuses to leave battle, though hes wounded.

And he kills Douglas and saves his father! S.d.: They fight. The King being in danger, enter the Prince of Wales. Then defeats Hotspur His gallantry to the defeated, dead Hotspur, finishing his last sentence. His double gallantry to brother John and to Douglas. Stage image: Hal between Hotspur and Falstaff On stage Falstaff appears dead; we need to forget what we know from stage direction: Falstaff who fall(s) down as if he were dead. To audience, Falstaff appears dead.

Hotspur also dead. Prince Hal stands between them. To return to humors theme: Hal appears the tempered mean between the two extremes. Oh, I should have a heavy miss of thee/ If I were much in love with vanity. But now he has emerged from vanity of tavern world, and has won the honor that Hotspur had striven for. But Falstaff riseth up Sblood, twas time to counterfeit. Counterfeit? I lie; I am no counterfeit. To die is to be a counterfeit, for he is but the counterfeit of a man who hath not the life of a man; but to

counterfeit dying when a man thereby liveth, is to be no counterfeit, but the true and perfect image of life indeed. The better part of valor is discretion, in the which better part I have saved my life. Take that Hotspur! Literally! Therefore, sirrah, with a new wound in your thigh, come you along with me. So Vanity bears off Honor? Where does this leave Hal?

He has saved his father (his true father). He has defeated rebellion. And killed the gallant Hotspur. He has emerged from the tavern world. He has performed princely valor. And now can appear the strong leader his father had yearned for. But is the issue of legitimacy solved? Rebellion Henry in final scene: Thus ever did rebellion find rebuke.

Well, not exactly. But Worcester, a cause of the battle, is executed. Vernon too. Lots of mopping up to be done. Rebellion in this land shall lose his sway,/ Meeting the check of such another day. But theres still Northumberland, the Archbishop of York, Glendower and Mortimer. The political effect of the play? Is kingship now a matter of performance, appearance? Is honor a reality, or a dangerous concept? Can legitimacy ever be restored to the

monarchy? Whats the Falstaff effect on the political world?

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Brendon Gallacher - Weebly

    Brendon Gallacher - Weebly

    Brendon Gallacher is a poem about belief in imaginary friends, who are fictional beings conjured from the mind often to provide companionship to a lonely individual. The poem advances through the stages of a child's belief of her friend, and...
  • Woods; Classifications and Examples Natural Woods  Hardwoods: beech,

    Woods; Classifications and Examples Natural Woods Hardwoods: beech,

    Man Made Boards · Man-made boards: plywood, aero ply, flexiply, marine ply, chipboard, MDF and hardboard · Applications; furniture, work surfaces and exterior projects . Laminates . and veneers · Veneers such as beech, ash, oak, walnut, paper and foil...
  • By Y. Ath Slide 1-1 Section 1 Angles

    By Y. Ath Slide 1-1 Section 1 Angles

    This is incorrect, however, since both sin θ and cos θ must be in the interval [-1,1]. Method 1 Example 17 Use the identity to find sec θ. Then use the reciprocal identity to find cos θ. Choose the negative...
  • DNA and RNA as Genetic Material

    DNA and RNA as Genetic Material

    C value paradox. C-value is the amount of DNA contained within a haploid nucleus (e.g. a gamete) or one half the amount in a diploid somatic cell of a eukaryotic organism. C value paradox - the amount of DNA in...
  • The Civil War "Soldiers Experience"

    The Civil War "Soldiers Experience"

    Common Instruments in Camp. Fife-(high pitched flute) Bugle-often used as a signal of when to get up, go to sleep, eat etc. Drum-beat used to assist marching regiments. Confederate and Union Brass Bands-served as a morale booster and motivator during...
  • Now, knowing classical logic we move to model

    Now, knowing classical logic we move to model

    The problem is like Muddy Children with three children but the children can give non-unique answers, like k or k+1 children are muddy. But this is only when not enough information immediately available. We have to introduce time. When the...
  • Strong Introduction

    Strong Introduction

    Outlining The purpose of outlining is to get all of your ideas organized before you start writing the actual paper. This should help ensure that:
  • Teaching, Learning & Leading Ellen Rass Vice-Principal Dr.Denison

    Teaching, Learning & Leading Ellen Rass Vice-Principal Dr.Denison

    Teaching, Learning & Leading Ellen Rass Vice-Principal Dr.Denison SS York Region District School Board "Seeks to improve student achievement … and transform teacher professional practice through the use of broadband and information communications technologies (ICT).