Intro to Public Forum Debate - Columbia Public Schools

Intro to Public Forum Debate - Columbia Public Schools

Intro to Public Forum Debate What is Public Forum Debate? Partner debate Purpose- for the common man Much easier to understand, and thus to judge, than especially Policy but even Lincoln Douglas Debate (created because the other debates were so complicated) Topic changes each month Accessible to anyone

Types of Public Forum Topics Public Forum, or PF (pronounced puff), topics are all current, popular, and much debated issues Ex. NSA, immigration reform, climate change, foreign policy in the Middle East, the rise of China, health insurance, and the Supreme Court Resolutions are released at the first of the month prior to the month the topic will be debated

Types of Resolutions Three types or categories of resolutions that Public Forum debates fall under Course-of-action debates Cost-benefit analysis debates Comparison debates Most resolutions will fall under these three categories Course-of-action debates Debates that revolve around debating the

merits of a course of action Characterized by should in the resolution Verbs following should may include: Suspend Require Abolish May also include a moral obligation to take a course of action or to do something Course-of-action debates, cont.

Should debates will have the following categories of arguments: Moral (is it moral?) Feasibility (is it possible?) Practicality (is it reasonable?) The action will usually not have already taken place (will be in the future) There are also should not debates In this case, the PRO side will affirm that the course of action should not be taken and the CON will advocate that it should be taken

Course-of-action examples December 2013 Resolved: Immigration reform should include a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrations living in the United States. March 2013 Resolved: The United States government should not require its citizens to have health insurance. February 2012 Resolved: Birthright citizenship should be abolished in the United States.

Cost-benefit Analysis Debates Debates that require you to evaluate and debate the costs and the benefits of an specific idea, institution, or decision Words that characterize these debates Undermines Threatens Harms Outweighs Benefits Not all of these debates will explicitly

say in the resolution costs or benefits!! Cost-benefit Analysis Debates, cont. These resolutions may be broad or specific Could require the debate to focus on a specific harm or benefit or cost Occasionally use the phrase on balance to equalize the debate (if you see this its a cost-benefit analysis debate!) Also may ask to uphold or justify a previous decision or evaluate the

implications of the decision Examples of CostBenefit Analysis Broad Debates Specific November 2013 Resolved: The benefits of domestic surveillance by the NSA outweigh the harms. January 2012 Resolved: The costs of a college education outweigh

the benefits. January 2013 - Resolved: On balance, the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission harms the election process. February 2013 Resolved: On balance, the rise of China is beneficial to the interests of the United States.

Comparison Debates Resolutions that direct a comparison between two options in the round May have two different solutions/options to fix a problem Words to look for: Prioritize Is preferable Should replace Have to research both options thoroughly! The debate will be a clash between BOTH the costs and the benefits for BOTH options

Comparison Resolutions, cont. December 2012 Resolved: The United States should prioritize tax increases over spending cuts. November 2011 Resolved: Direct popular vote should replace electoral vote in presidential elections. October 2011 Resolved: Private sector investment in human space exploration is preferable to public sector investment.

What type of debate is this? Resolved: The United States should suspend all assistance to Pakistan. Resolved: In the United States, current income disparities threaten democratic ideals. Resolved: Developed countries have a moral obligation to mitigate the effects of climate change. Why was this exercise important?

Its important to know what type of debate you will be participating in, in order to know the types of arguments The type sets up the framework of the debate Framework is what shapes the round The resolution is the initially framework in a debate, because it gives you what to talk about The value in LD and an observation in Public Forum further clarify framework in a round Observations A type of framework Useful to make the resolution more balanced to

your side (some resolutions inherently favor one side over the other) Used for clarification of what you want the round to look like or what should be talked about Should be limited in use but are crucial to understand so if another team as an unfair observation, you are prepared to adequately attack it Like a value in LD, gives the judge a criteria to judge upon Examples Resolved: The U.S. government should not require its

citizens to have health insurance. Observation one: the Affordable Care Act is only an example of a law that includes a mandate to purchase health insurance, meaning the debate should not be limited only to this act. Resolved: the United States should suspend all assistance to Pakistan. Observation one: in order for the PRO side to win todays debate, they must prove that every form of assistance should be suspended. If any form of assistance stands at the end of the round the CON side wins todays debate

Public Forum Cases Like in LD, Public Forum Debates begin with each side reading their cases. This time, each case is 4 minutes long. Cases will include The resolution Definitions Any observations 2 or more contentions Before we clarify how to write a case, lets brainstorm what should be included in this months cases.

January 2016 Resolved: On balance, economic sanctions are reducing the threat Russia poses to Western interests. What TYPE of debate will this be? Right, a cost-benefit debate! Now, brainstorm Definitionsthink, what should we define? And what definitions

should we use if we are PRO and CON? Will each case require different definitions? Any observations? What will this debate look like? January 2016 Resolved: On balance, economic sanctions Topic Analysis Split into two groups Each group should come up with 5 arguments for the PRO Side and 5 for the CON Side

May need to quickly look things up! (cite possible evidence) Think of the categories used in on balance debates (Undermines, Threatens, Harms, Outweighs, Benefits) Think of the effects of sanctions on Russia and Western interestsbe ready to share! January 2016 Resolved: On balance, economic sanctions are reducing the threat Russia poses to Western interests.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Chapter 12 Investing in Stocks

    Chapter 12 Investing in Stocks

    White board breakdowns-Types of Investing. ... The fund managers use this pooled money to buy stocks, bonds, and other securities. ... It exists both in brick-and-mortar and in cyberspace. It is customer friendly and responsive to customer questions and needs.
  • NANDA, NIC And NOC Overview

    NANDA, NIC And NOC Overview

    NOC The nursing outcomes classification (NOC) is a classification of nurse sensitive outcomes NOC outcomes and indicators "allow for measurement of the patient, family, or community outcome at any point on a continuum from most negative to most positive and...
  • Growing Vegetables in Containers Master Gardeners of Grays

    Growing Vegetables in Containers Master Gardeners of Grays

    6 to 10 inch pots = lettuce, radish, green onion, parsley and herbs. 1 to 2 gallon = chard and dwarf tomatoes. 5 gallon = most vegetable crops such as tomatoes, peppers and eggplant. ... Most vegetables that will grow...
  • Sensors and Transducers - Harvey Mudd College

    Sensors and Transducers - Harvey Mudd College

    Apply Sensors Checklist to the Theodolite. Physics: pendulum points down and user points at rocket. Second order system calculation ?0=??=9.80.1≈10 ???/?. Flights take 2-3 seconds before apogee. ~90 notches: 1/degree. I can't aim to 1 degree. Readout is manual /...
  • SNs Internal Audit and Compliance Organization Integrated GRC

    SNs Internal Audit and Compliance Organization Integrated GRC

    2015 - PMI of IA and Compliance teams. ... Written report and presentation in AC/MB. Delivery to Board: March. Q1 - Risk Inventory. Q2 - KRI & New Risks. Content: Tracking of key risk indicators sufficient to identify trends in...
  • sip.asso.fr

    sip.asso.fr

    ASSEMBLÉE GÉNÉRALE ORDINAIRE DU 27 mai 2014 Ordre du jour Feuille de présence, quorum, Président et Secrétaire de séance Bilan des actions 2013 Approbation des comptes 2013 et quitus au CA pour sa gestion Actions proposées pour 2013 Présentation et...
  • Increasing biogas production by thermal (70 C) sludge pre ...

    Increasing biogas production by thermal (70 C) sludge pre ...

    Total dissolved solids and volatile dissolved solids increased after thermal pre-treatment, as expected . 1.5 g increase VDS in raw sludge compared to 11.9-13.9 g VDS after 9, 24, and 48 h pre-treatment. This means that the proportion of soluble...
  • Business Issues Chapter 10 pp. 329-380 2018 National

    Business Issues Chapter 10 pp. 329-380 2018 National

    Qualified Business Income Deduction W-2 Wage Limitation pp. 338-339. Joint return & multiple businesses. Compute tentative QBI deduction for each - applying wage limit if applicable. Combine tentative QBI deductions. Deduct lesser of #2 or 20% x taxable income (w/o...