Judicial Administraiton in Canada

Judicial Administraiton in Canada

Judicial Administration in Canada September 26, 2007 Court Organization and Trial Court Reform Todays topics The criminal trial process in Canada Canadian court structure Millar and Baar, ch. 4 Greene, ch. 1 McCormick, ch. 3 Baar, Trial Court Reorganization in Canada: Alternative Futures for Criminal Courts (2003) The criminal trial process in Canada First appearance If in custody, bail hearing If not in custody, set date for trial If had bail hearing, second appearance is to set date

There might be a third appearance to set date if additional time is required to apply for legal aid or retain counsel, or obtain disclosure from the crown prosecutor Three types of offences Less serious: prosecution by summary conviction (eg. communicate for the purpose of obtaining the sexual services of a prostitute, cause disturbance, harassing telephone calls) Most serious: indictable (murder, aggravated sexual assault; fingerprinted and added to CIPC registry) Hybrids can be prosecuted either by summary conviction or by indictment. The crown elects which way to proceed. (eg impaired driving, assault, theft under $5,000) pretrial Can be between defendants lawyer and crown, or with both lawyers and a judge.

Often for plea negotiations Explore disclosure issues Narrow trial issues Lawyers and informations Once a lawyer is retained for an accused person, the lawyer is on the record, and must represent the accused unless fired (with courts permission), or forced to withdraw because client asks him/her to do something unethical The official start of a case is the laying of the information filing a sworn document setting out charges. Usually filed by police or crown; any private person can lay an information before a JP Prodecures by indictment For many, accused can elect to have a trial by jury in the

Superior Court, or a trial by judge alone in the Provincial Court (called Ontario Court of Justice in Ontario) or the Superior Court (for more serious cases). Even if an accused elects trial by jury, prior to the trial the accused can re-elect to have a trial by a judge alone. Why would an accused re-elect? Why would an accused prefer trial by jury or trial by judge alone? Preliminary hearing: for serious cases destined for trial in the Superior Court by judge alone or by jury, a preliminary hearing is scheduled in the Provincial Court to determine whether there is enough evidence for the case to go to trial. The crown can decide to proceed with a direct indictment no preliminary hearing. Yesterday, after the start of a preliminary hearing on the terrorism case in Brampton, the crown decided to issue a preferred indictment. The preliminary hearing was stopped, and the case will go directly to trial in the Superior Court. A preferred indictment is rare.

The Canadian Court System, 2004 ___________________________ | | federal appointments | Supreme Court of Canada | and administration | 9 judges | |_________________________| _______________| | ____|____ ________________|________________ federal |Federal | | |federal appointments

|Court of | | 10 provincial & 3 territorial |appointments, & admin. |Appeal 15 | | courts of appeal |provincial _____|_______| | 128 judges | administration _____|___ __|____ |_______________________________| | Tax | |Federal | | | | Court | |Court32| |

| |__ | 27___| |-------| | | | | ______________________ | federal | | | appointments,| provincial superior | | provincial | trial courts | | administration | 829 judges | |

|_____________________| | |____________| | | ___________|___________ | | provincial | pure provincial and | appointments | territorial courts | & admin. |________984 judges_____ Millar & Baar, Chapter 4 Discussion of constitutional basis Section 96 Section 92(14)

Numbers of judges and court structure out of date see previous slide for current information Since Chapter 4 written, all provinces have merged their county or district courts with their superior courts Issues from the merger that still haunt the court system Unified family courts Unified trial courts: criminal & civil (small claims issues) Ontarios experiment with attempting to create a unified court system Greene, ch. 1 History of courts Structure and function of Canadian courts integrated system vs. dual system (as in US) Judicial impartiality Judicial appointment

Judicial education Judicial discipline Role of courts in democracy (p 16) McCormick, ch. 3 Principles Identify routine cases and assign to high-volume low delay court Assign less routine and more serious cases to a lower-volume court Establish a regional court of appeal Establish a general court of appeal Create specialized federal courts for some kinds of federal cases (administrative law and tax law) The Section 96 dilemma How specialized should courts be? How user-friendly should courts be? How big should courts be?

Baar, Trial Court Reorganization in Canada: Alternative Futures for Criminal Courts (2003) Specialization: provincial courts specializing more on criminal matters, and superior courts on civil matters Specialization of court in the UK: family, criminal, civil Shifting of criminal matters from Superior to Provincial courts (s. 96 to s. 92(14) Increased caseload for provincial courts has shifted work to lower courts municipal courts and JP courts Ell case

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • A2C Capita FHE Conference 8th May 2014 - Scomis

    A2C Capita FHE Conference 8th May 2014 - Scomis

    November resits, Functional Skills, January entries, Welsh Bacc registrations processed. November exam results in January. Spring/Summer 2016. Pearson to go-live in time for summer entries. AQA to go-live September 2016. C&G and NCFE ready but SIMS functionality hadn't been developed.
  • Frog Body Parts and Functions - KEVIN COEN

    Frog Body Parts and Functions - KEVIN COEN

    Leopard Frog Classification Domain - Eukarya Kingdom - Animalia Phylum - Chordata Subphylum - Verebrata Superclass - Skip This Class - Amphibia
  • PTT 07MAR2016 - Leigh's Science Resource

    PTT 07MAR2016 - Leigh's Science Resource

    PTT 07MAR2016. What are the similarities between these two skeletal systems? ... OAJ #21 - Friday. Skeletal and Muscular Systems . The systems work together to create movement. Skeletal provides the frame and Muscles provide the movement ... Explain how...
  • Slide Title in 48pt. Garamond

    Slide Title in 48pt. Garamond

    Relationship between Density and Pavement Life. Low Density. Permeability. Segregation. Poor adhesion at interface "You must plan for the longitudinal joint, it cannot be an afterthought".. ... Mark a consistent, straight line for paver operator.
  • Burnsville Traveling Baseball Pre-Tryout Information Meeting

    Burnsville Traveling Baseball Pre-Tryout Information Meeting

    Burnsville Traveling Baseball Pre-Tryout Information Meeting Wednesday, March 7, 2018 BTB 2018 Parent Meeting * BTB 2018 Parent Meeting * Catching: The purpose of the catching evaluation is to give the potential coaches a look at potential catchers.
  • Don't "Float Your Quote" - PBworks

    Don't "Float Your Quote" - PBworks

    Final Considerations When you blend a quotation into a sentence, be sure that the quoted material fits grammatically into the sentence. For example, be sure that what you end up with is a complete sentence and not a sentence fragment....
  • The Monkey's Paw

    The Monkey's Paw

    The Monkey's Paw By W.W. Jacobs Obj: Use background information and vocabulary to help interpret and analyze story Terms to Know short for "checkmate," the winning move in a chess game Mate Arabian Nights A collection of ancient tales from...
  • lawson21summer2017.weebly.com


    If you have not decided on a topic yet, try writing a thesis for each topic you are thinking about. I will give you all about 15 minutes to come up with two or three tentative thesis statements. When I...