Lecture 4 Theories of globalisation - Masarykova univerzita

Lecture 4 Theories of globalisation - Masarykova univerzita

Lecture 4 Theories of globalisation 15 March 2006 the g-word Globe (from L. globus) 1551 "sphere," "round mass, sphere Sense of "planet earth," or a three-dimensional map of it first used in 1553 Globalization first used in 1959

1962: the noun appears in the Oxford English dictionary But three decades passed before G was developed in social sciences as a paradigm Hyperinflation in the use of the term G is applied to almost everything the most abused word of the 21st century (The Economist) G is both a discursive and a descriptive

concept how we understand G has much to do with our political views and theoretical standing G is a terrain of conflicting discourses How to explain G? Because G has many layers and dimensions, a good theory must explain its complexity A theory needs to be adaptable in defining G because the world is changing: a new

world society is still being formed: The global age needs a new theory Theories of G (Lechner & Boli, 2005)

1. World system theory 2. Neorealism/neoliberal institutionalism 3. World polity theory 4. World culture theory 1. World System Theory Reflected in readings from Immanuel Wallerstein, Leslie Sklair In the 1950s, the dominant theory was

modernisation theory; its problem was that some countries were not developing/ modernising as predicted evidence did not fit theory hence... 1. World System Theory WST developed out of attempt to explain the failure of certain states to develop Looking at Latin America, their economies could not compete, global capitalism forced

certain countries into under-development Trade is asymmetrical Poor countries are dependent on rich states 1. World System Theory

Key concepts: CORE: rich & developed states PERIPHERY: poor & dependent states SEMI-PERIPHERY: the in-between tampon zone; semi-industrialised states Semiperiphery keeps the system stable 1. World System Theory Trade & investment concentration The core dictates the terms of trade

Dependency makes the situation of peripheral states even worse (they may even lose their political autonomy) The world system perpetuates dominance by the core & dependency of the periphery G perpetuates inequality global economic system is inherently unfair 1. World System Theory International organisations do not influence

the fundamental position of core and periphery because most NGOs and IGOs are created by core countries The idea that governments and international institutions can make the system fair is an illusion (because they always reflect interests of capitalists) 2. Neorealism Realism and Neorealism dominant in IR theory for

several decades Realisms central claim: states are dominant actors in world politics; driven by desire to survive and become more powerful (war, military competition) Critique of R: states no longer in constant struggle for survival; economic and social issues matter; R better suited to explain 18th and 19th c. situation 2. Neoliberal institutionalism Reflected in Robert Keohane & Joseph Nye:

complex interdependence Critical response to realism: G produces a more complex system of interdependent states; societies are interconnected in many ways; power and security are not the only thing that matters states interact over many different kinds of issues 2. Neoliberal institutionalism Military force is no longer seen as being

central to inter-state relations; international organisations are the centre of global politics To understand global politics, we have to study what goes on in international organisations (e.g. WTO) 2. Neoliberal institutionalism World society contains many centres of power; there is no one, single power hierarchy

Transnational rules and organisations now have much more influence States are still important but the system is one of interdependence - other organisations also influence world politics in critical ways The use of force is less effective; no hierarchy of issues exists that would be the same for all states 3. World polity theory Developed in response to modernisation

theory, WST and R Reflected in John W. Meyer et.al. Polity = activities and associations of the public, political sphere World polity = political structures, associations and culture in the international sphere 3. World polity theory Contrary to observations of other theories, WPT is

focused on the fact that societies have been becoming more similar in terms of their government and state policies Isomorphism: trying to account for a world whose societies ... are structurally similar in many unexpected dimensions and change in unexpectedly similar ways 3. World polity theory

States govern on the basis of cognitive models (which come from the culture and society) associations, IGOs and NGOs and other states transmit models of how to govern Worldwide models are constructed and reproduced through global cultural and associational processes models embedded in an overarching world culture States modify their traditions in the direction of worldcultural forms/prescriptions/principles WPT is based on a totally different theory of action: it emphasises the influence of norms and culture not power

4. World culture theory A response to world polity theory Reflected in Roland Robertson, Arjun Appadurai, Ulf Hannerz World culture is new and important BUT it is not as homogeneous as WPT claims 4. World culture theory World society is a complex set of relations among many

different units in the global field People are becoming aware of the new global reality the problem of how to live together in one global system G compresses the world into a single entity; the emphasis is on cultural compression all cultures are becoming subcultures within a larger entity = global ecumene This does not mean homogenisation but organisation of diversity We will come back to creolisation, glocalisation...

Readings for Lecture 5: Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy Arjun Appadurai The Global Ecumene Ulf Hannerz If you want: Roland Robertson Glocalization: Time-Space and Homogeneity-Heterogeneity in Global Modernities

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Présentation PowerPoint

    Présentation PowerPoint

    centre-val-de-loire.direccte.gouv.fr. Direction régionale des entreprises, de la concurrence, de la consommation, du travail et de l'emploi (Direccte) du Centre-Val de Loire
  • Condenser Water Loop Renovations - txaee.org

    Condenser Water Loop Renovations - txaee.org

    Six total cooling tower fans, each rated at 60 hp (360 total hp). Six total condenser water pumps, each rated at 80 hp (480 total hp.) Sam Houston Plant - A Brief Description. Not the largest plant in town -...
  • Dot Plots & Box Plots - Kyrene School District

    Dot Plots & Box Plots - Kyrene School District

    - Make dot plots, histograms, box plots and two-way frequency tables. - Calculate standard deviation. - Identify normal distribution of data (bell curve) and convey what it means. With help from the. teacher, the student has. partial success with summarizing...
  • Sentence Patterns 4 & 5 - Lawndale High School

    Sentence Patterns 4 & 5 - Lawndale High School

    Sentence Patterns 4 & 5 Pattern 4: a series without a conjunction A, B, C Separate items by commas Effects gives your sentence a quick, staccato sound Each item receives equal emphasis Parallel in Form and Function Awkward sentences: The...
  • Federal Advisory Committee on Juvenile Justice (FACJJ) Webinar

    Federal Advisory Committee on Juvenile Justice (FACJJ) Webinar

    FACJJ Chair and Vice Chair discussion regarding Dalene Dutton as FACJJ member and FACJJ Chair exiting the FACJJ advisory council. Jim Moeser as Vice Chair would assume the role of FACJJ Chair on October 1, 2015 and would complete the...
  • Lees: II Petrus 1:1-15 Teks:  II Petrus 1:2

    Lees: II Petrus 1:1-15 Teks: II Petrus 1:2

    Teks: 2 Petrus 1:2. Nuwejaar! 1Van Simon Petrus, 'n dienaar en apostel van Jesus Christus. Aan dié wat deur die regverdige beskikking van ons God en Verlosser, Jesus Christus, dieselfde kosbare geloof as ons ontvang het.
  • Strengthening the links 3  April 2015 This event

    Strengthening the links 3 April 2015 This event

    Support is available from the Joint Improvement Team (JIT). Improvement tools are on the website, there are events and road-shows planned, and a JIT lead is attached to every partnership. ... NHS Quality Improvement Scotland ...
  • Artefacts from Donegal County Museum

    Artefacts from Donegal County Museum

    T-shaped scraper. Microlith - one of manmade tools from flint - from very small for shrew to large for Elk ... Chisel not photographed - point of antler with piece of bronze at tip. Bronze hammer. Resin used as glue...