Mechanisms versus Difference-Making

Mechanisms versus Difference-Making

Mechanisms versus Difference-Making Examples from genetics and molecular biology Gry Oftedal 2009 University of Oslo Goal Use scientific practice to shed some alternative light on the philosophical causation debate Suggestions: Difference-making and counterfactual analyses mainly

consider an epistemological notion of causation, while production/mechanisms/physical connection views mainly consider an ontological notion of causation. Therefore, these different analyses need not be in direct competition, as they may consider different levels of causal information Two causal assumptions in genetics and molecular biology 1. A cause makes a difference to the effect

2. There is a causal mechanism that links cause and effect Mechanism: a continuous and dynamic chain or network of interactions between objects, sometimes on different levels, connecting the proposed cause and the relevant effect. Two lines of philosophical inquiry Difference-making and counterfactual

analysis Production/mechanism/physical connection analysis Difference-making and epistemology Experiment: If the introduced variation or difference in the proposed cause-variable is correlated with a variation or difference in the effect-variable, this is seen as a strong indication of causation. Example: If you did not take this vitamin, you would not have caught that cold

Crucial observation: Difference-making approaches in science and in philosophy are about identifying/picking out causes of a certain effect Difference-making and counterfactual analysis = our access to causation Mills Method of Difference: If an instance in which the phenomenon under

investigation occurs, and an instance in which it does not occur have every circumstance in common save one, that one occurring only in the former; the circumstance in which alone the two instances differ, is the effect, or the cause, or an indispensable part of the cause, of the phenomenon (Mill 1974 [1843], 391). Mechanisms and ontology Next step in a biological investigation: finding the mechanism that explains the link between cause and effect Not

captured in counterfactual terms: causation is a structural relation that underlies and supports causal dependencies Mechanisms: a pursuit to capture this underlying structural relation Lurking counterfactuals Psillos (2004): (t)there is a sense, (), in which the

counterfactual approach (a fortiori the dependence approach) is more basic than the mechanistic (a fortiori the productive) one in that a proper account of mechanisms depends on counterfactuals while counterfactuals need not be supported by (or depend on) mechanisms. Mackie (1980) There are three kinds of analysis: factual, conceptual and epistemic. It is one thing to ask what causation is in the objects, as a feature of a world that is wholly objective and independent of our thoughts, another to ask what concepts

of causation we have, and yet another to ask what causation is in the objects as far as we know it how we know what we do about it. Counterfactual dependence and production Ned Hall: Two concepts or two kinds of causation: counterfactual dependence and production Example: June

The rainfall in April as a cause of a fire in rainfall is a producer of structural change/change in physical and biological interactions connecting the rainfall and the fire, and thereby a productive cause of it. Concluding remarks There is an asymmetry between causal analyses in terms of counterfactual dependence and causal analyses in terms of mechanisms; the first mainly considers access to causes, how we

pick out causes, the second mainly considers explanation of causal links and causal structure Both these levels of investigation and analysis are indispensible and build on each other in biological research

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • 18531890 Starry Night Oil on Canvas, 1889 Vincent

    18531890 Starry Night Oil on Canvas, 1889 Vincent

    Van Gogh's finest works were produced in less than three years in a technique that grew more and more impassioned in brushstroke, and intense color, and in the movement and vibration of form and line. He was an emotional painter...
  • Characterisation of EO systems - TERENA

    Characterisation of EO systems - TERENA

    ESA Earth Observation High Speed Network (HiSEEN) Rhodes, 10th June 2004 Agenda The ESA Earth Observation use of NREN/GEANT Network solution Technical description Pre-operations schedule Challenges Implementation Operational Issues for discussion Conclusions and way forward The ESA Earth Observation use...
  • Best of ILC 2018 Viral hepatitis About these

    Best of ILC 2018 Viral hepatitis About these

    Long-term virological and clinical outcomes in patients with cirrhosis who achieve SVR after DAA treatment are being evaluated in the DALTON cirrhosis registry study. Objective: to evaluate clinical progression or liver disease reversal after SVR and SVR durability. Cirrhosis registry...

    PLC Norms. Develop your norms and violation of norms: As a team, agree on no more than five norms (less is more!) As a team, agree on action steps for responding when someone on the team is not following the...
  • Presentación de PowerPoint

    Presentación de PowerPoint

    hay distintos tipos, el más extendido en el LDC es el "gráfico de Levey-Jennings", en el cual los resultados de control son expresados en el eje de ordenadas con respecto al tiempo o a las determinaciones sucesivas en el eje...
  • Diapositive 1

    Diapositive 1

    Terrassement Gaz Chauffe eau solaire Fondation Dalle Gouttière Poteau Lambrequin Mur Volet Poutre Fenêtre Toiture Porte Quitter Source Encyclopédie, Revue professionnelle, Manuel BTP, Site Interne.
  • Chinese New Year chun jie  Xin Nian kuai

    Chinese New Year chun jie Xin Nian kuai

    The Lantern Festival Happy new year Happy new year Happy new year Happy new year to you all We are singing We are dancing Happy new year to you all Xin nian ge Xin nian hao ya Xin nian hao...
  • Defibrillator, pacemakers and icd - Pheonix India

    Defibrillator, pacemakers and icd - Pheonix India

    Implantable cardioverter- defibrillator. Important to differentiate from other thoracic devices esp pacemaker in v/o electromagnetic interference(EMI) Previously placed in an abdominal pocket; present day pectoral placement. Can be differentiated using a CXR to examine the RV lead system.