Responding to national curriculum goals for English language

Responding to national curriculum goals for English language

Responding to national curriculum goals for English language learners: enhancing reading strategies in high school content areas. Teachers and teacher educators as co-researchers: an action research project. Jennifer Alford, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane. Alice Windeyer, Education Queensland. Presented at AATE/ALEA National Conference, July 5-7, 2013. Brisbane. CRICOS No. 00213J Queensland University of Technology Publication: Journal of Immersion and Content-based Language Education. (in press, Spring 2014). Contact: [email protected] a university for the real R world

CRICOS No. 00213J Overview of presentation: Intro why this? why now?; Overview of Kedron High School ESL unit and Alices class; Action research model; Action research reading focus in this project; 3 sub-focus areas with snapshots from lessons and reflections; Implications/recommendations; References. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Introduction why this?;why now? Context: Growing cultural and linguistic diversity; Over 5000 students in Queensland high schools in Australia are migrants or

refugees or are from backgrounds other than English (DET, ESL Database, 2011). a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Language and Content integration 1980s: Language Across the Curriculum (LAC) movement spread to Australia promoting a student-centred, language learning focus in all discipline areas. Corson (1990, 1993) extended this to include second language given growing representation of bilingual learners in English-speaking countries.

In Queensland, government-funded programs such as the English Language Development Across the Curriculum project (Commins, Houston & Lambart, 1989). Such holistic, cross-curricula programs have withered (p. 372) due to reductionist views of literacy and compartmentalisation of discipline areas that better serve highstakes testing (May & Wright, 2007). Mainstreaming has become the norm (Davison, 2001) with a range of approaches incl: i. ESL in-class support, with or without significant collaboration with mainstream content teachers. ii. parallel programs for groups of English language learners - same content but modified with a stronger language focus (Davison, 2001; Gibbons, 2002). Withdrawal and support models each have strengths and weaknesses and these have been well documented (Coyle, Hood and Marsh, 2010; Davison, 2001; Harklau, 1999; Gibbons, 2002). a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

Ge ogr aph y Content area literacy is specialised according to the discipline area. Some aspects of literacy and language that are common to a range of subject areas, each discipline area will produce and demand different lexicogrammatical and rhetorical textual features that reflect and construct the knowledge of that area, in dynamic ways (Wyatt-Smith and Cumming, 1999). Paying attention to the language of the discipline area can help students develop content knowledge at the same time they develop more advanced reading skills (Fang and Schleppegrell, 2008, p. 10, our emphasis). Within Geography, such language includes: Simultaneous weaving between knowledge constructs and the language that reflects and generates this knowledge is a pedagogical challenge for many teachers and EAL/D students (Creese, 2005). a university for the real R

world CRICOS No. 00213J ACARA imperatives Each area of the curriculum has language structures and vocabulary particular to its learning domain, and these are best taught in the context in which they are used. All teachers are responsible for teaching the language and literacy demands of their learning areas. (ACARA, 2012, p. 2). Critical juncture regarding the way expertise might be developed, perceived and exchanged between content and language teachers through collaboration, in order for the goals of English language learners in content areas to be realised. a university for the real R world

CRICOS No. 00213J The problem of collaboration not a pretty picture. Problematic identities and social practices EAL/D teachers navigate when working collaboratively with content area teachers. Collaboration between EAL/D and curriculum content teachers is challenging and requires particular attitudes and practices to make it successful. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J a university for the real

R world CRICOS No. 00213J Dual focus 1. Teaching reading strategies with EAL learners within curriculum content Geography (Immediate). 2.Strengthening Alices position as a knowledgeable teacher of English language for further collaboration with content-area teachers (Long term). a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

ESL support provisions at Kedron Numbers within the language unit fluctuate around 200 students An equal number of students receive support within mainstream classes. ESL unit Mainstream classes English HPE Maths Arts Science Technology History Special language support Form class + assembly class Two levels of classes Higher class working to parallel mainstream / adjusted assessment Lower class elements of mainstream curriculum / highly adjusted assessment

a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Entry pathways to the intensive English language unit Kedron State High School Bandscales 3 - 5 a university for the real Bandscales 6 + R world

CRICOS No. 00213J a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Reading Bandscales SALIENT POINTS FROM THIS?? a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J ACARA EAL/D Learning Progression

Developing level Students at the Developing level can speak one or more languages/ dialects, including functional English, and have a developing knowledge of print literacy in English They purposefully engage with curriculum demands with increasing success. ..They produce increasingly extended pieces of spoken and written English (although they may be more proficient in one mode than the other), which include their own innovations with the language. However, they are still developing control over English grammar and building their vocabulary; hence, they continue to need explicit language to be taught, and teaching strategies supportive of EAL/D learners, particularly with academic language of subject disciplines. They are increasingly able to use English sufficiently to demonstrate their understanding of content and thus meet some of the achievement standards for their year level, as described in the Australian Curriculum (ACARA, 2012, p. 31). http://www.acara.edu.au/curriculum/student_diversity/eald_teacher_resource.html a university for the real

R world CRICOS No. 00213J Student snapshots Hsar Karen. Mehry - Iranian. (Burmese ethnic minority) parents are academics who are studying in Australia a refugee who grew up in a refugee camp in Thailand. had learnt English as a foreign language; has a strong level of Karen people in camps English. have well-organized Justine - Papua New Guinea. education system

has grown up speaking English hungry to learn and get was spending time in the class to ahead in Australia consolidate confidence to work with the often have different text types and develop academic skills. world knowledge; dont have basic Denise Sudan. understanding of came to Australia as a refugee over five concepts expected by years ago our education system has extremely competent social needsahighly university forscaffolded the real world CRICOS No. 00213J language skills, steps to achieve a task R Action Research model a form of self-reflective enquiry undertaken by participants

in social situations in order to improve the rationality and justice of their own practices, their understanding of these practices and the situations in which the practices are carried out (Carr & Kemis, p. 162). Central concepts in AR (Burns, 2009): i. empowering participants in a social situation; ii. self-consciously criticising what exists through becoming aware of assumptions that influence the social situation; iii. working to confront inequities in the system; iv. deliberate intervention with recurring reflection that adjusts the project as required. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Teachers and teacher educators researching together.... Academics in the Real World project (2011) Professional development session with all EAL/D teachers at Kedron High - comprehensive review of current literature on

reading comprehension [Karen Dooley]. Discussion with the teachers to identify the particular areas they wanted to focus on with particular classes culminating in a range of issues being brainstormed. Each academic teamed up with one of the teachers our mutual interest in content-based reading. Classroom observations were then made by the academics and many ensuing one-on-one discussions with the teachers to tease out particular areas of concern and the strategies to employ. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J By the end of year 9, students should be able.... to use a number of active comprehension strategies to interpret texts, including activating prior knowledge, predicting, questioning,

identifying main ideas, inferring, monitoring, summarising and reflecting (QSA, 2007 p.3). a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Joint observations of student difficulty in relation to negotiating particular reading tasks.... Limited vocabulary both general academic and discipline-specific; Still developing skills in using context and in identifying genre or language signals to help them navigate a text. Able to read a text aloud with reasonable fluency, but real processing of the meaning and their ability to retell was quite weak. Needed much practise in identifying gaps in their knowledge after reading and synthesizing ideas. a university for the

real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Contd... Difficulty: retaining the ideas in the content read in previous sentences in order to construct meaning at paragraph and whole text level; recognizing the relationship between clauses in complex sentences; handling new vocabulary while also acquiring new content knowledge. a university for the real R world

CRICOS No. 00213J The action research project Alices initial goals: To help students become aware of their role as readers; To help them proactively use reading strategies when tackling reading tasks; To assist learners to be able to confidently read for and extract relevant information from a range of web sites and other source materials during their independent research on endangered animals. To enhance students ability to go beyond basic information retrieval to more in- depth processing of text . a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Effective Reading Comprehension Strategies

1. Summarising 2. Forming questions 3. Answering questions and elaborative interrogation 4. Activating prior knowledge 5. Monitoring comprehension (metacognition) * 6. Using text-structure awareness * 7. Using visual graphics and graphic organisers 8. Inferencing a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Focus area: Meta-cognitive reading strategies Metacognition is the ability to think about and control the thinking process before, during, and after reading. Students who have learned metacognitive skills can plan and monitor their

comprehension, adapting and modifying their reading accordingly. ..Ineffective readers, on the other hand, often dont realize they should be doing something while reading except moving their eyes across the page. They are unaware of the complexities of reading and have never been taught to think about what they are reading, create mental pictures, or ask questions. (Urquhart & Fareez, 2012. p. 4). Many strategies included, for example: Having a reason for reading and being aware of this; Recognising text structure at discourse and clause level; Identifying the main idea and important details; Relating text to background knowledge; Recognising relevance of a text to reading goals; Recognizing and attending to difficulties; Reading carefully. (Grabe, 2009) a university for the real

R world CRICOS No. 00213J Xu (2010) also notes the value of metacognitive strategies with additional language learners in terms of making the content more visible or tangible. BUT difficult to teach as there are so many ways students monitor their comprehension and little empirical research has been done on this with second language learners. (Grabe, 2009) a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

Involves recognizing and attending to: Levels of importance of info in text; Heading and subheadings; Paragraph choices; Co-referential connections across ideas; Relations of part-to-part and part-to-whole; Transition forms and signal words; Patterns for organizing text information (e.g., cause and effect, problem and solution, comparison and contrast, description, classification, analysis, argument and evidence, procedural sequence, chronological ordering top level structure). a university for the real R

world CRICOS No. 00213J Snap shots of practice a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J 1. Scanning for meaning a university for the real R world

CRICOS No. 00213J a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J What worked Students gained greater confidence to scan through dense text Paid attention to headings Forced to consider strategies, not only complete task Students enjoyed a challenge / competitive Reflection on skills Not all students able to complete Part 2 with same degree of

competency Would they automatically transfer skills when working independently? More practice needed a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J 2. Drawing attention to signal words Lexical signalling or noticing the words in academic texts that signal patterns of text organisation and relationships between ideas. Paying attention to signal words, such as those that indicate cause and effect (e.g., due to; as a result; is caused by), does improve reading comprehension particularly among less-skilled readers. (Chung, 2000;Meyer & Poon, 2001). a university for the

real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Extract taken from website (1) for the first reading lesson. Giving reasons why Every year, sharks are killed in various fisheries, either intentionally for their fins and meat or accidentally as bycatch. Shark finning, to provide for delicacies like shark fin soup, is one of the biggest threats facing sharks. They are usually finned alive and the body is thrown back into the water where the shark either bleeds to death or drowns. With bycatch, they generally become accidentally entangled in fishing lines or nets put out in the ocean to catch other species of fish, and when fishermen haul in their catch, the dead or dying sharks are thrown back into the water. Like other marine life, sharks are increasingly threatened by climate changes that are altering ocean circulation, sea surface temperatures, and even the chemistry and salinity of the ocean.

Reasons within reasons Sharks associated with coral reefs, for instance, are susceptible to the loss of those diverse and productive ecosystems as bleaching and disease kill off coral. From Alaska to the Adriatic Sea, (shark) sightings and captures indicate that numerous shark species are showing up outside of their normal ranges, which could be an indication that climate-induced food web changes are taking a toll. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J See handout for task - worksheet 1. Reflection:

Students often fell into a rhythm of working hard to complete the task and not focusing on the process. Alice: Thinking meta-cognitively about their thinking is a new concept for them. While they were clearly engaged in the process, did they actually have the ability or the language skills to explain their thoughts? Oracy is an added dimension. Students seemed more focussed on the content aspects of the task despite our intense focus on language. Creese (2005) found a similar situation in her study in a Yr 10 Geography class in a London school. While the teacher attempted to keep the EAL students focussed on the language of Geography, their objective was to get the answer (p. 198). Creese suggests this is directly related to what is valued in schools, i.e., curriculum content which is tested, even in those schools with inclusive policies that aim to meet both language and content objectives. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

3. Identifying organisation structure in texts Recognising relationships between ideas in texts by using the texts organisational patterns and associated language (Adams & Dutro, 2005; Ogle, 2010). Making explicit this connection between language and content can assist learners to see the purpose of the language being employed, thereby raising meta-cognitive awareness. Typical organisational patterns in expository texts include listing in temporal sequence; compare/contrast; problem/solution; and cause/ effect. (Semantic relations). Students benefit from being able to recognize a texts organizational pattern because they are able to read the information with specific questions in mind. That is, each organizational pattern suggests a series of questions that are answered within the text. Answering these questions helps students comprehend the intended message (Urquhart and Fareez, 2012, p.26). a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

Website extract 2 Shark Declines Threaten Shellfish Stocks, Study Says Helen Scales for National Geographic News March 29, 2007 http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2007/03/070329-sharks-shellfish.html 1. Dramatic declines of large North Atlantic sharks due to overfishing have upset the balance of entire marine ecosystems, a new study shows. Now scallops, clams, and oysters are paying the price. 2. Smaller sharks, skates, and rays that are normally eaten by the large sharks have become so abundant that they are decimating shellfish stocks, the researchers say. 3. This shark decline, fed by growing worldwide demand for shark-fin soup, is indirectly causing some scallop fisheries to collapse entirely, the scientists add. 4. A recent study, which appears in this week's issue of the journal Science, is the first ever demonstration of how wiping out top-level predators causes impacts that cascade down through the rest of the food web, the study authors say. 5. "Commercial fishing has left so few big sharks that they no longer perform their role as the top predators," said study co-author Julia Baum of Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia. "The predators of smaller species of sharks and rays have been virtually wiped out. 6. In new research, marine biologists discovered some species have declined by 99 percent and more. What was most alarming was that all 11 major species of predatory sharkincluding sandbar, blacktip, tiger, hammerhead, and bull sharksdrastically declined. As a result, 12 other smaller prey shark and

rays species shot up in abundance. 7. "Twenty years ago the abundance of rays was not sufficient to cause a decrease in the population of scallops. With the arrival of more rays, the scallop populations have been decimated, and the area's century-old fishery has closed. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J See handout for worksheet 2 Reflection:

This lesson on top-level structure - Cause and Effect - felt rushed. The whole class approach we used in order to explain the meta-cognitive dimension and to keep this at the forefront meant that a few of the weaker students who were struggling were not adequately catered for. Whole class needed teacher guidance to deal with the new concepts, but they all worked at very different speeds and some needed one-on-one assistance. We wonder how the task could be set up to enable students to work in small ability groups or independently at their own pace while, again, retaining a clear focus on language. In addition, we observed that for some the chosen authentic website text appeared too challenging; for others, any easier and there would have been no meta-cognitive challenge. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

Implications for the future... Focused language work like this, needs to be a regular, articulated part of classroom practice to reinforce its value, and to generate the skills and confidence to do it. Whole school approach supported by education authorities would mobilise teachers to deepen their knowledge of content-related language demands in relation to their particular student cohorts. Language teachers need to investigate the language demands of Geography and other content areas more deliberately, as Alice did, to identify the literacy practices within Geography that create opportunities for learning. The Geography teacher can gain understanding of the constellation of interacting grammatical and discourse features (Schleppegrell, 2004, p. 76) that realise the discipline area. Research this collaboration in relation to ACARAs EAL/D agenda. Particularity is the key as language learners have differing needs depending on a range of variables such as first language variety, level of literacy in the first language, and proficiency in the target language. This was clearly evident in our attempt to teach top level text structure with learners at level 4 in this group. ACARA EAL/D Learning Area annotations are helpful ....to a degree. See also EQ Teaching Emphases website. Professional associations for both content and language areas can cross-fertilise to

bring the topic of language and content integration into greater focus in publications and conference themes and in teacher education programs. This would help break down the silo mentality that leaves teachers of curriculum content with fewer resources for teaching language, and teachers of language with inadequate access to knowledge of curriculum content. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Conclusion. This small study has... Enhanced one teachers ability to make meta-cognition a stronger feature in her reading instruction with a particular group of EAL/D learners. The impetus for the project came from two sources. Alice recognised her need for reinvigoration in the area of teaching reading strategies that would assist her learners to access literate practices in English within Geography. Secondly, the project aimed to address Arkoudis (2006) call for teachers of EAL/D to be skilled in establishing their knowledge-base authority. The action research project has positioned Alice more

confidently for future collaboration with content teachers in order to implement the national curriculums commitment to catering for EAL/ D learners in content areas. All teachers in Australia, and in many other English-speaking countries, now need to meet this challenging curriculum mandate. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J References

Alvermann, D., Phelps, S., & Gillis, V. (2010). Content literacy and the reading process. In Content Area Reading and Literacy succeeding in todays diverse classrooms. (6th Edn). Boston: Allyn & Bacon/Pearson. Arkoudis, S. (2006). Negotiating the rough ground between EAL/D and mainstream teachers. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 9(4) 415-43. Australian Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA). (2012). English as an Additional Language Teacher Resource Overview and EAL/D Learning Progression Foundation to Year 10. Retrieved from http://www.acara.edu.au/curriculum/student_diversity/eald_teacher_resource.html. Aug 29, 2012. Banegas, D. L. (2012). Integrating content and language in English language teaching in secondary education: models, benefits and challenges. Studies in Second Language Learning and Teaching 2 (1). 111-136. Creese, A. (2002). The discursive construction of power in teaching partnerships: Language and subject specialists in mainstream schools. TESOL Quarterly, 36 (2) 597-616. Creese, A. (2005). Is this content-based language teaching? Linguistics and Education 16. 188-204. Davison, C. (2001). Current policies, programs and practices in school ESL. In B. Mohan, C. Leung, and C. Davison (Eds.), English as a Second Language in the mainstream - teaching, learning and identity. (pp. 30-50). Harlow, UK: Pearson Education. Davison. C. (2006). Collaboration between EAL/D and content teachers: How do we know when we are doing it right? International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 9 (4) 454-475. Department of Education and Training, Queensland. (2011). ESL Database data. Personal communication. Date received March 3, 2011. Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. Fang, Z., & Schleppegrell, M.J. (2008). Technicality and Reasoning in Science: Beyond Vocabulary. Reading in secondary content areas: a language-based pedagogy. (pp. 18-38). Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

Gibbons, P. (2002). Scaffolding Language, Scaffolding Learning : Teaching Second Language Learners in the Mainstream Classroom. Portsmouth: Heinemann. Grabe, W. (2009). Building Main Idea Comprehension. Reading in a second language: moving from theory to practice. (pp. 198-219). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J Hammond, J. (2012). Hope and challenge in The Australian Curriculum: Implications for EAL students and their teachers. Australian Journal of Language and Literacy. 35, (1) 223-240 May, S., & Wright, N. (2007). Secondary literacy across the curriculum: challenges and possibilities. Language

and Education, 21(5), 370-376. Queensland Studies Authority (QSA). (2007). Queensland Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Framework: English Essential Learnings by end of Year 9: Reading and Viewing. p. 3. Retrieved from: http://www.qsa.qld.edu.au/downloads/early_middle/qcar_el_english_yr9.pdf July 29, 2011. Schleppegrell, M, (2004). Linguistic Features of Academic Registers. The Language of Schooling. A Functional Linguistics Perspective. pp. 43-76. Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum. Urquhart, V., & Frazee, D. (2012). Teaching reading in the content areas if not me, then who? (3rd ed) Midcontinent Research for Education and Learning: Denver, Colorado. Wyatt-Smith, C.M., & Cumming, J.J. (1999). Examining the literacy demands of the enacted curriculum. Literacy Learning: Secondary Thoughts, 7(2), 19-31 a university for the real R world CRICOS No. 00213J

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Enzymes - ScienceGeek.net

    Enzymes - ScienceGeek.net

    enzymes are proteins that catalyze biochemical reactions without altering the reaction equilibrium and the activities of enzymes depend on the temperature, ionic conditions, and the pH of the surroundings. ... Enzyme: A biological catalyst that is usually a protein. Substrate:...
  •  VPN  2015  1   1 2 3  VPN  1.1

    VPN 2015 1 1 2 3 VPN 1.1

    无线网、邮件、vpn使用介绍 信息化办公室 2015年1月 主要内容 无线网连接设置 1 邮件的多种登录方式 2 校外通过vpn方式访问校内图书馆资源 3 1.1 无线校园网的ssid 我校无线校园网接入点为: ccnu-auto(适合各类移动终端,有wifi信号即自动联网) ccnu(适合笔记本电脑及访客用户,使用网页登录) ccnu(小写 ...
  • Introduction to Data Warehousing - unibz

    Introduction to Data Warehousing - unibz

    Data Warehouse Models and OLAP Operations Enrico Franconi CS 636 Data Warehouse Architecture Decision Support Information technology to help the knowledge worker (executive, manager, analyst) make faster & better decisions "What were the sales volumes by region and product category...
  • Fronts and Air Masses

    Fronts and Air Masses

    Fronts and Air Masses By Brian Fontaine 1. An air mass is a large body of air that has similar temperature and moisture throughout. Air Masses are named for their place of origin and source of moisture.
  • Poetry - carlisle.kyschools.us

    Poetry - carlisle.kyschools.us

    Rhythm: Pattern of beats or stresses in spoken or written language Simile: A figure of speech that uses like or as to make a direct comparison between two unlike ideas My love is like a red rose. 21. Sonnet: -...
  • 1. dia - Teremtesvedelem.hu

    1. dia - Teremtesvedelem.hu

    Isten mindezeket kifejezetten az ember javára és uralkodására tervezte: semmi más célja nem volt az egész teremtett világnak, mint hogy az ember céljait szolgálja."* (Ter 1,26: „Uralkodj!") „Mai tudományunk és technológiánk oly mértékben át van itatva a természettel szembeni ortodox...
  • Dual Credit Options Presented by TCC-Northeast Dual Credit

    Dual Credit Options Presented by TCC-Northeast Dual Credit

    Students will take the Reading, Writing, and Math portions of the TSI-A. Pre-Assessment Activity (PAA) ... Students are required to make a TCC grade of "C" or better in ALL Dual Credit courses to continue in the Dual Credit Program....
  • Intramolecular Forces - Lompoc Unified School District

    Intramolecular Forces - Lompoc Unified School District

    - individual molecules attracted to one another through intramolecular forces - not anywhere near as strong as networks - ex: water. ... Hydrogen Bonding . Attraction between hydrogen atom in one molecule and an unshared pair of electrons on the...