SCED Limit Calculation Matthew Young/Jian Chen 9/15/2017 Problem

SCED Limit Calculation Matthew Young/Jian Chen 9/15/2017 Problem

SCED Limit Calculation Matthew Young/Jian Chen 9/15/2017 Problem Overview When the MW limit for a transmission constraint is calculated, there is a possibility for abnormally low limit results if the flow over the constrained equipment is very small. Resulting in the constraint binding at an unrealistic MW limit. PUBLIC 2 Current SCED Limit Calculation (Constant Power Factor) The SCED MW limit of the active constraint is calculated by EMS. The real and reactive flows are used to calculate the current power factor.

The power factor is presumed to remain constant from one SCED run to the next. The power factor is then applied to the MVA limit to get the MW limit. PUBLIC 3 Existing problem When calculating the PF, if P << Q, the resulting MW limit can be very low in relation to the actual equipment rating. PUBLIC 4 Impact to SCED As a result, a very low MW limit could be sent to SCED,

causing a high shadow price in SCED dispatch. SZEPCMN8: HLD_FMR1 on 5/17/2017 PUBLIC 5 Review of similar events Since Jan.1 2012, there have been 11 similar events, when MW limits dropped below 20% of MVA ratings and caused high shadow prices (>$1000) in SCED. Date 6/14/2012 8/23/2012 12/9/2012 12/28/2012 2/21/2013 5/19/2015

5/3/2017 5/14/2017 5/17/2017 5/28/2017 7/21/2017 PUBLIC Contingency XLOB58 XLOB58 XVE2R89 BASE CASE SAJORIO5 SCRDLOF9 SKLELOY8 SSCLWF28 SZEPCMN8 XFTS89 XFTS89

Constraint NLARSW_PS1 NLARSW_PS1 PAUL_69-1 SNYDR_FMR1 RIOHONDO_345L POS_SHAN_1 LOYOLA_69_1 NVKSW_FMR1 HLD_FMR1 PIGTAP_SOLSTI1_1 PIGTAP_SOLSTI1_1 Daily Limit Min 38.9 49.4 4.8 6.2 1.2

0.3 0.9 7.7 0.2 0.3 1.4 Max SP with Low Lim $3,500.00 $1,855.25 $2,800.00 $1,111.72 $3,500.00 $2,800.00 $3,500.00 $3,500.00 $2,165.75 $3,500.00 $3,500.00

Binding with Low Limit 2 1 1 1 8 1 2 1 1 1 1 6 Alternative Method One alternative method to calculate the SCED MW limit is based on the assumption that the change in reactive power through the

constrained equipment will be small and can be ignored. As shown in the above equation, this method would run into problems when reactive flow is higher than equipment rating. To prevent this from happening, a hybrid-method is suggested: PUBLIC 7 Method Comparisons PUBLIC 8 Method Comparisons

PUBLIC 9 Method Comparisons Test with all active constraints from July, 2017. Total of 16,718 SCED constraint intervals are tested. MW limit/MVA rating 80%~100% PUBLIC Constant Power Factor Hybrid PF/MVAR 16623

16718 60~80% 49 0 40~60% 23 0 20~40% 12 0

0~20% 11 0 10 Method Comparisons PUBLIC 11 Conclusion Constant Power Factor Method Unrealistic MW limits could be sent to SCED when the power factor of a constraint is

very low. Based off of historical data, there were few of these events since Jan.1, 2012, with minimal impact to the market. Hybrid PF/MVAR Method Could present the opportunity for some MVA limit overshoot. While a possible solution to unrealistic MW limits, would affect all constraints going forward. PUBLIC 12

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • CurricUNET Linking Faculty, Staff and Administration for Curriculum

    CurricUNET Linking Faculty, Staff and Administration for Curriculum

    CurricUNET Linking Faculty, Staff and Administration for Curriculum Management ... Manager [email protected] Curriculum and Instructional Services San Diego Community College District (619) 388-6963 CurricUNET Linking Faculty, Staff and Administration for Curriculum Management What is CurricUNET
  • Part II: Preparation/Process - Professor Mark J. Grossman

    Part II: Preparation/Process - Professor Mark J. Grossman

    Receiver's Bias: Peer Groups and Media. Peer pressure influences the way messages are perceived. Peer groups influence attitudes and actions. Media is a powerful agenda setter - tells us what issues are important
  • Aims of the STP

    Aims of the STP

    5. DRAFT. Proposed STP Governance Structure. STP Oversight Board - to lead on alignment of sovereign bodies with STP vision, to ensure Boards are committed to the transformation and to support in the management of external stakeholders (as appropriate).
  • CDL Testing and Commercial Learner&#x27;s Permit Standards

    CDL Testing and Commercial Learner's Permit Standards

    Federal Updates DOT Medical Certificate Electronic reporting of DOT Physicals for all CDL drivers From Certified Medical Examiner to FMCSA From FMCSA to State Effective date: June 22, 2018 (will be delayed) Federal Updates Entry Level Driver Training (ELDT) Minimum...
  • Forced Migration Case Study: Zimbabwe to South Africa

    Forced Migration Case Study: Zimbabwe to South Africa

    -Interlocking spurs. Georesource.co.uk Higher Hydrosphere V- Shaped Valley Georesource.co.uk Higher Hydrosphere The tallest waterfall in the world is Angel Falls in Venezuela which drops 979m. Niagara Falls, on the other hand, is only 51m high! Georesource.co.uk Higher Hydrosphere Largest ...
  • Biblical EQ www.aibi.ph/beq/

    Biblical EQ www.aibi.ph/beq/

    Biblical EQ www.aibi.ph/beq/ © Copyright, John Edmiston 2001 A Christian Handbook For Emotional Transformation Part 6 - The Learning Organization
  • Executive Functions - PolicyWise

    Executive Functions - PolicyWise

    The combination of high level of reactivity with a high level of regulation predicting better executive functioning would be consistent with an optimal arousal hypothesis. Observed reactivity and regulation in response to a fear evoking mask presentation task
  • How to Embed Quotations - scott.k12.ky.us

    How to Embed Quotations - scott.k12.ky.us

    Lead in phrases for embedding quotes. Signal phrases (also known as "lead ins") are words or phrases, in the text of the paper, that indicate to the reader that someone else's work is going to be used. The signal phrase...