# Aside on AI Will computers ever be intelligent?

Aside on AI Will computers ever be intelligent? Really intelligent? Tasks that previously were thought to require intelligence: adding and subtracting playing chess driving a car recognizing speech or handwriting

translating to a foreign language proving mathematical theorems What does it mean to say that a computer is intelligent? Is that the same as being a person? What is a person? Is a computer program a person? Is a person a computer program? Achieving Intelligence How do AI program achieve intelligent behavior? Traditional AI: symbolic knowledge representation and search Machine learning Statistical algorithms Neural nets and deep learning

Statistical machine learning Gather much training data Design a statistical model Train, train, train Given new instances, use model to categorize or predict Neural Nets

Model behavior of neurons Each neuron has many Inputs Output is weighted sum of inputs Training: adjusting the weights to improve behavior Learning: networks improve performance with time Feedback: large networks with feedback have very complicated behavior (pondering? dreams?) Success: many (small) problems are handled well; bigger problems are problematic (but Symbolic AI Represent a problem as a collection of logic (symbolic) statements

Often triples: subject, predicate, object [graph edges] Characterize the initial condition symbolically Characterize goal state symbolically Characterize actions that are possible in the world as productions or changes to the initial condition Search through possible actions to find a path to the goal Search in Artificial Intelligence Represent your problem as a graph where nodes are states and edges are operators that go between states

Define problem states (nodes) Identify start and goal states Define operators (edges) Use DFS or BFS to find goal Example: Missionaries and cannibals problem states: (3,3,1) 3 missionaries, 3 cannibals, and 1 boat on left side of river. Operators: one or two people cross the river in the boat, so that there isnt a cannibal majority on either side. Goal: get to the other side? Moves? (331)(220)(321)(210)(221)(020)(031)(010)(021) Computer Chess

How would you program a computer to play chess? Brute force or intelligence? The slow ris e of computer chess Game Playing We could use DFS butcant search whole tree! limit depth of search and use an evaluation function We could use DFS buthow do we know which move the opponent will choose?

minimax algorithm: assume the opponent does what looks best. i.e. at nodes where it is the humans turn, pick the move that looks best for human. Where computers turn, pick the move that looks best for the computer DFS/BFS Resource Requirements DFS: Runtime? O(n), n=number of nodes expanded Space required? O(d), d = depth of search Can I cut off a search after 3 seconds? BFS: Runtime? O(n)

Space required? O(breadth of tree) = O(bd), b=branching factor Can I cut off a search after 3 seconds? Staged DFS: do a DFS of depth 1, 2, 3, until out of time Runtime? O(n) Space required? O(d) Mankalah An ancient gamed called Kalah or Mankalah uses stones and pits: 6 to a side and one on each end. 4 stones are initially placed in each side pit. None are in the end pits (called Kalahs a players kalah is on her right). A move consists of picking up the stones in a pit and distributing them, one at a time, in successive pits.

If the last stone is placed in your Kalah, you go again If the last stone is placed in an empty pit on your side, you capture the stones in that pit and the opposite one, on the opponents side of the board. These are put into your Kalah. The game ends when one player has no stones left; the other player puts all the remaining stones on her side into her Kalah. Whoever ends with more stones in her Kalah wins. Can you make your Kalah program smarter than Bonzo? Mankalah minimax Result minimaxVal(Board b, int d) // d is depth if (b.GameOver() or d==0) return new Result(0, evaluate(b)) if (b.whoseMove()==Board.TOP) //TOP is MAX bestVal = -infinity

for (move=first; move<=last; move++) if (b.legalMove(move) [and time not expired]) Board b1 = new Board(b) //duplicate board b1.makeMove(move) //make the move val=minimaxVal(b1,d-1) //find its value if (val>bestVal) //remember if best bestVal=val; bestMove=move else // similarly for BOTTOMs move return new Result(bestMove,bestVal); Parallelizing minimax? Algorithm- or data-parallelism? C# Task Parallel Library (TPL) Other ideas for improving play?

Better evaluation function Optimize program speed Parallel processing Learning for feature-weight tuning Opening or closing book Alpha-beta pruning with move reordering Theoretically, search up to twice as deep, though actual results vary Heuristic Search Techniques What do you do when the search space is very large or infinite? [e.g. Google maps]

Well study three more AI search algorithms: Backtracking search Greedy search (Best-first) A* Example: the 8-puzzle How would you use symbolic AI techniques to solve the 8-puzzle problem? Symbolic AI solution Start state: 5 4 0 6 1 8 7 3 2 (e.g.) Goal state: 1 2 3 8 0 4 7 6 5 Edges: sliding a tile. From start state:

548610732 504618732 What search algorithm should I use? Backtracking search Start at the start state Search in any direction Backtrack when stuck This is really the same asDepth-first search Used very frequently E.g. Perl regular expression matching E.g. finding a traveling salesmans circuit E.g. graph coloring

Is there any way I can be smarter than a blind search? 09-08-04 How to get from Arad to Bucharest? How to get from Isai to Fagaras? Greedy Search (Best-first) Best-first search: like DFS, but pick the path that gets you closest to the goal first Need a measure of distance from the goal h(n) = estimated cost of cheapest path from n to goal h(n) is a heuristic

Analysis Greed tends to work quite well for some problems (despite being one of the seven deadly sins) But, it doesnt always find the shortest path Susceptible to false starts A* Can we apply the ideas of Dijkstras algorithm? Pay attention to total path length, not just distance to the goal f(n) = g(n) + h(n) g(n) = distance traveled so far h(n) = estimated remaining distance (heuristic)

A*: do a DFS-like search with lowest f(n) first Does this guarantee an optimal Optimality of A* Suppose h(n) never overestimates (such heuristics are called admissible) Note that f(n) always increases as search progresses A* is complete and optimal (though often slower than best-first search) The first limitation you are likely to run into with A* search: not enough RAM in your computer

Heuristics for the 8-puzzle What would a good, admissible heuristic be for the 8-puzzle? h1: number of tiles out of place h2: total distance of squares from destinations Results of A* Consider solving the 8-puzzle by search, using the following algorithms

DFS BFS IDS (iterative deepening search): like staged DFS. A* with heuristic h1 A* with heuristic h2 Will each be able to find the shortest solution? Which one will find it most quickly? Search Cost IDS A*(h1) Effective Branching Factor A*(h2) IDS A*(h1)

A*(h2) 2 10 6 6 2.45 1.79 1.79 4 112 13 12 2.87

1.48 1.45 6 680 20 18 2.73 1.34 1.30 8 6384 39 25

2.80 1.33 1.24 10 47127 93 39 2.79 1.38 1.22 12 364404 227

73 2.78 1.42 1.24 14 3473941 539 113 2.83 1.44 1.23 16 1301

211 1.45 1.25 18 3056 363 1.46 1.26 20 7276 676 1.47 1.27

22 18094 1219 1.48 1.28 24 39135 1641 1.48 1.26 Machine Learning How would you write a program to play Go?

Branching factor approaches 400 DeepMinds AlphaGo AI and Personhood AI proponents: a machine as complex as a brain would be as intelligent as a person maybe it would be a person. Hidden assumptions:

intelligence: I/O, storage, and processing capabilities the brain: a machine whose function can be duplicated by other machines (and function is what matters) a person: an intelligent hunk of meat What makes a person? Is there anything to being a person besides intelligence? Consciousness: is it an epiphenomenon or can it affect the body? Will: do we make real choices, or are they determined by the laws of physics? Affections: is there a love algorithm?

Spirit: is there a human capability to know God beyond the five sense? Moral responsibility: what are you doing when you kick your computer punishment? What are these views called? all the world (including the brain and mind) operate according to physical laws There is a part of the mind (or soul or spirit) that is outside of nature, exempt from physical laws Materialism [or metaphysical materialism]

Dualism [or Cartesian dualism] The mind is the program running on the wet-ware of the brain Functionalism [or non-reductive Non-Reductive Materialism Characteristics there is no non-physical part of a person mental processes can be localized in the brain consciousness, will, etc. are real, but they are an emergent property of brain function Questions

How could there be a real will or moral responsibility? Where is the intensionality or meaning? What then can a verse like Matt. 10:28 mean? [Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. ] What about the existence of angels, God if there is no second substance? What of church history and doctrine? Cartesian Dualism Characteristics

The soul is a second substance, created by God, like the Angels The mind is a faculty of the soul, and it can affect the body Whatever the brain does, it is not the mind Questions A second substance is messy Where does this soul come from? How does it affect the body without breaking the laws of nature? It seems that current research is localizing more and more mental processes in the brain What does this do to the science of AI?

## Recently Viewed Presentations

• Using MLA Style 7th Edition writingcenter.txstate.edu + + + + + + + + + + + + + + Why MLA? There are two main reasons we use MLA citation: To have a uniformed convention for documenting research To...
• Marine LIFE ZONES. ESTUARIES. COASTAL MARSHES (WETLANDS) MANGROVE SWAMPS (FORESTS) CORAL REEFS. COASTLINES. OCEANS. Estuary and Coastal Wetlands. Estuaries are rivers that meet the sea where seawater mixes with freshwater (brackish water). Coastal wetlands .
• In total, 47 different honey samples provided by beekeepers and one sample of honey from the market, that has proved to be pure isoglucose syrup (called as "syrup" below), have been analyzed. The botanical origin and their authenticity have been...
• Characteristics of Hebrew Poetry . Emblematic - comparisons (like or as) - Ps. 103:12-13. As far as the east is from the west, So far has He removed our transgressions from us. Just as a father has compassion on his...
• 1 Ó 1997 Irwin/McGraw-Hill, A Division of the McGraw-Hill Companies PowerPoint Supplement developed by: William E. Youngdahl World Business Department Thunderbird, The American Graduate School of International Management Production and Operations Management: Manufacturing and Services PowerPoint Presentation for Chapter 1...
• Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare ... Maria warns Sir Toby that Olivia is losing patience with his rowdy ways and with a foolish knight named Sir Andrew Aguecheek that Toby brought to be a suitor for Olivia. Sir Andrew joins...
• The Steel Workers' union accused automobile executives of trying to steal their benefits. 10. If you pull a tendon in your heel, it can take several weeks to heal (i.e. to regain your health). * Polysemes are spelled the same...
• It will be available as an e- learning module and will be hosted on the Money Advice Scotland portal and AiB's Financial Health Service website. Where a debtor does not have access to online services, the trustee must inform AiB,...