Public Deficit or Private Surplus? - University of Ottawa
THE REAL LIMITS OF FISCAL POLICY ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTION QUESTION What might fiscal policy look like if the policy world was comprised of modern monetary theorists? ANSWER It dependsbut will sketch one possible path DISCUSSION ROADMAP 1. Introduction An assumption
2. Metaphors and Truth Some stylized evidence 3. Measuring the MMT Constraint Three approaches 4. Identifying Progressive Principles Five shared objectives 5. The
Public Goods Campaign Some immodest proposals 6. Marketing MMT A short, medium and long term strategy I. INTRODUCTION: AN ASSUMPTION FIVE-STEP LEARNING PROCESS 1. Ignorance 2. Denial/Ridicule 3. Intrigue/Testing 4.
Logical conversion 5. Emotional conversion YOU ARE HERE II. METAPHORS AND TRUTH THE POWER OF METAPHOR Countries
High are Like Households Debt High Default Risk High Interest Rates Solution: Reduce spending, raise taxes, generate surpluses, pay down debt Portugal, Ireland, Greece Borrowing Costs: 2011-2012 Portuga l Irelan
d Greece Percent of GDP Japan: The Flow 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12
Japanese Deficit/GDP Ratio Japan: The Stock Japanese government gross financial liabilities - as a percentage of GDP 200 180 160 2011: New Debt Issuance = 50% of GDP! 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0
y a u o a u e e a u c a p u c a p u o e a u o e u e e a u e e a u c a p M 9 -A -N -M 8 -J 8-S 8-D -M 6-J 6- O 0 -J 4 -A 0 -J 0 -O 3-J 8 -A 2 -A -N 7 -F - M 0 -A - N 6 -F 4 -J 5 -S 5 -D -M 4 -J 4 -S 8 -D -M 9 -J 1 -O 2 -J 3 -A 2 7 2 2 8 0 7 1 1 1 26 0 0 1 1 2 2 2 2 0 02 0 16 2 19 2 0 0 0 13 2 2 2 31 0 1 1 1 SOME TAKE-AWAYS 1. Household budget metaphor not applicable to sovereign nations 2. Quantitative easing does not cause inflation 3. Because we worry about being the next
Greece, we will be next Japan III. Measuring the Constraint PRINCIPLES 1. Taxes do not fund sovereign spending but are used to ground moneys value and incentivize behaviours 2. Macro policy should be set based on real constraints 3. Three broad types of constraints Capacity constraint Financial balances constraint
Political constraint Capacity Constraints: Okuns Law Okuns Law Y = GDP Growth; k = natural growth rate c = coefficient relating changes in unemployment (U) to GDP growth rate. Capacity Constraints: Okuns Law Values k = 2% (popn growth = 1% + 1% productivity growth) c = 2 (previous estimates) Objective: drop unemployment rate by 4
percentage points to 3.5% Capacity Constraints: Okuns Law Calculation ) = 10% 2010 GDP = $1.6 trillion so increase GDP by $160 billion to hit 3.5% Assume Multiplier = 1.5 Implies $106 billion fiscal expansion $117 billion if k= 3% Capacity Constraints: Okuns Law HOW BIG IS $106 BILLION? Current spending (program + interest costs) = $275
billion so 39% increase Deficit implications One-Shot Expenditure 2011-12 deficit of $146.1 billion or 9% of GDP. Less than USA. Spread over 5 years = additional $21.2 billion/year of deficit spending (4% of GDP in 2011-12 and declining thereafter) Financial Balance Constraint 15% 1 0.9 10% 0.8
SUM OF BALANCES = 0 POLITICAL CONSTRAINT 1. Communication constraints (how to overcome the media wall) 2. Expectations constraints (how to generate a vigorous political discussion) 3. Federalism constraints (how to manage federal/provincial relations)
IV. Progressive Policy Principles 1. Job creation 2. Flattening the income distribution; 3. Respecting ecological constraints; 4. Empowering local decision-making; 5.
Concern for social justice (race, gender, housing, education, health) V. The Public Goods Campaign 1. JOB GUARANTEE 2. INFRASTRUCTURE EXPANSION 3. HEALTH/EDUCATION GUARANTEES 4.
TAX POLICY CHANGES 1. JOB GUARANTEE Objective: Good job to anyone willing and able to work April 2011: 1.4 million unemployed workers Offer Wage: $10/hour Cost Estimate: $29 billion for Year1 2. INFRASTRUCTURE EXPANSION Share of Gov't Gross Fixed Capital Expenditure in GDP 0.06 Public investment strategy Target 5% and hold to 2015 = $200 billion in spending
0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 Average Government Gross Fixed Capital Expenditure, 1984 - 2008 = 2.7% 0.01 0 Implied back to normal trajectory
$200 BILLION BUYS A LOT OF INFRASTRUCTURE IN Transportation: mass transit, high-speed rail, broadband strategy, roads, bridges, bicycle lanes Public health: improved water works, sewage treatment, parks Community/Cultural spaces: arenas, curling rinks, skateboard parks, tennis courts, theatres, public art Environment: housing retrofits, new building materials, transportation strategies (see above) 3. EDUCATION/HEALTH-CARE INITIATIVES Free public education / expand
college/university hiring Universal drug coverage Fund urban design based on health considerations Rethink food/agriculture policy 4. TAX POLICY CHANGES Reduce income taxation; reduce GST, maintain or increase GST tax credit Eliminate regressive payroll taxes and related fictions (EI account) Eliminate CPP deductions and convert into pay-as-you-go plan funded by federal government. Get rid of CPPIB
Increase sin taxes, capital gains taxes, dividend taxes, taxes on energy Cap or reduce tax-preferred plans (TFSA, RRSPs, RESPs) V. COMMUNICATING CHANGE Short term concrete policies, Aikido and the household borrowing metaphor. Target = general public/populist Medium term Build institutional capacity. Target = young economists/social scientists Long term Wall of messaging. Target = policy elite.
Program Rationale: Should articulate integrated brand promotion. Communication vehicle: Which type of PR tools & how will be used? Message Content: Focus group/ in-depth interviews can be conducted for the meaningful message of the product/ co. Basic Public Relation Strategies...
Coh-Metrix analyzes texts on over 50 types of cohesion relations and over 200 measures of language, text, and readability. ... Flesch Reading Ease ＝ 206.835 － 1.015 × ASL ... 1978). This occurs when a noun, pronoun, or NP in...
Must have an approved waiver in place. Student must take class. Course Equivalency. Must have approved waiver in place. High school only. Student cannot have ever taken the class . Optional Assessments. National Career Readiness Certificate (NCRC) HS guidance counselor.
Computer Architecture Lecture 1 Ann Gordon-Ross ... that it can be simulated within a VHDL-based hardware development framework Starting with the major components of a MIPS datapath Integrate the components and control logic into a processor implementing a subset of...
Velikost této energie odpovídá vykonané práci, to je EP = W = mgh. h Polohová (potencionální) energie tělesa souvisí s jeho polohou, např. v gravitačním poli Země. Těleso o hmotnosti m zdvižené do výšky h nad povrchem Země má polohovou...
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.CCRA.SL.2 Integrate and evaluate information presented in diverse media and formats, including visually, quantitatively, and orally. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.CCRA.SL.5 Make strategic use of digital media and visual displays of data to express information and enhance understanding of presentations.
Sad solo section Also, talk through the overall structure that you came up with at the end of the previous lesson. Get the instruments out . and split back into groups. Give the class just five minutes to remember their...
Ready to download the document? Go ahead and hit continue!