Progressive Design-Build: Examining the Structure, Procurement and Contracting

Progressive Design-Build: Examining the Structure, Procurement and Contracting

Progressive Design-Build: Examining the Structure, Procurement and Contracting Principles Michael C. Loulakis, Esq., DBIA Capital Project Strategies, LLC March 1, 2016 Introduction and Background Project delivery studies show benefits of: Early contractor involvement Highly qualified teams Group cohesion and team integration

Design-build offers opportunity to accomplish these goals But typical public sector design-build (fixed price) creates some challenges Why Owners May Decide Against Using Design-Build Owners desire to be involved throughout design process Direct contractual relationship with designer Interest in making all design decisions Owners ability to quickly respond to design submittals

Owners need to have design fully completed before construction Cost and time of a competitive, price-based, procurement Owners inherent ability to trust the contractor Progressive Design-Build Overall objectives Introduce design-builder to project early in design process Work in collaboration with owner to advance design Overall project price negotiated after design is developed

Single or two phase procurement process Pure qualifications-based Best value procurement with minimal price-based factors Progressive Design-Build (contd) Overall project price not meaningfully considered during procurement Open book estimating GMP/lump sum developed post-award Can establish this at 100% of design completion Normally see price commitment at 50-70% of design completion

Should be no Spearin liability, as there is no design handoff The typical approach for industrial and process design-build (i.e., EPC) Reasons Owners Choose Progressive over Fixed Price Design-Build Ability to introduce design-builder to the project as early as possible Design-builder becomes a strategic partner in planning and project definition Avoids Spearin liability

Facilitates having design-builder involved in permit and other development activity Substantially reduced cost and time for procurement helps everyone, including small design firms Reasons Owners Choose Progressive over Fixed Price Design-Build (contd) Owner interest in being involved in design and procurement Development of design solutions in conjunction with design-builder Direct discussions with design-builder on O&M/life cycle costing Procurement of subcontractors and suppliers

Owner access to real-time information Enhanced cost and schedule information during design development Facilitates designing to budget Open book pricing allows transparency into design-builders costs Process fosters collaborative relationships Reasons Owners Choose Fixed Price over Progressive Design-Build Statutory restrictions Mandates that overall price be provided at time of contract

Constraints on hiring and integrating subcontractors Owner interest in: Obtaining a competitive fixed price for entire project during procurement Developing detailed technical requirements prior to starting procurement Seeking different technical solutions through a competitive procurement process Owner concerns about exercising the contractual off-ramp Reasons Owners Choose Fixed Price

over Progressive Design-Build Statutory restrictions Mandates that overall price be provided at time of contract Constraints on hiring and integrating subcontractors Owner interest in: Obtaining a competitive fixed price for entire project during procurement Developing detailed technical requirements prior to starting procurement Seeking different technical solutions through a competitive procurement process

Owner concerns about exercising the contractual off-ramp Choosing Between CMAR and Progressive Design-Build Benefits of CMAR Ability of Owner to have a direct contract with a designer who is independent of contractor Easier ability to exercise off-ramp Benefits of progressive DB Owner does not have to manage/procure designer Slight schedule benefit Ability to obtain performance guarantee and other benefits of

design-build Elimination of Spearin liability Enhanced relationship between contractor and designer Fundamental Procurement Objective of Progressive Design-Build Keep the process as streamlined and simple as possible to pick the right team The right team is the one that: Will work well and collaboratively with the owner Group cohesion Team integration

Offers the best chance to meet the owners project goals and required outcomes The owner believes is trustworthy, fair, transparent and reasonable Key Issues to Assess Before Starting a Progressive DB Procurement Legal authority, and whether it will allow agency to use PDB in a way that accomplishes its goals Is the process clearly allowed? One step vs. two step process? QBS or best value? Self-performance requirements and limitations

Bonding requirements Specific evaluation factors Confirmation that agencys leadership is aligned with PDB process Key Issues to Assess Before Starting a Progressive DB Procurement (contd) Design status at start of procurement Market conditions, particularly in terms of number of interested teams Number of shortlisted firms (if two-step) Pass-fail or evaluated financial capacity

One or two contracts (i.e., preliminary services and/or entire design-build relationship) Form of contract (standard industry or one-off) Conditions to award and authorization of price (i.e., how many times does the board need to approve) How is Price Handled under Progressive Design-Build? Pure QBS No price information submitted whatsoever Price information submitted but not evaluated Opened after winner determined Used as a basis for negotiating a reasonable price

Best Value Price information often includes: Preliminary services fee Hourly rates Overall design-build fee Markup on wages of direct employees Anticipated general conditions Preliminary Services Create the Biggest Commercial Challenges Ability of design-builder to rely upon owner-furnished

information Design and cost submittal periods Cost estimating processes and assumptions Early work packages Subcontractor and vendor procurement Subcontractor and vendor involvement during preliminary services Establishing the

GMP/lump sum Owners off-ramp rights Liability for preliminary services Project Examples Dulles Rail, Phase I $1.6 billion contract for first phase of WMATA extension to airport Virginia PPTA procurement process Investment by design-builder in the preliminary engineering through unsolicited proposal

Negotiated lump sum price at completion of 30% design (preliminary engineering) after open book process Project on line 2014 Allowances used to overcome certain pricing issues Interim agreements used to address ROW/utility/design issues pending federal funding DC Water Headquarters New HQ to be built over an operating pumping station 2-phase procurement with shortlist of 3 Design competition iconic design that would satisfy permitting agencies, based on $55MM budget

$75,000 stipend Skanska USA Building, with Smith Group as lead architect Weighted criteria approach used for technical approach Solicitation of only lead constructor and lead designer Pricing information provided for informational purposes Single contract with two phases GMP proposal will be provided at 80% design Other Progressive Design-Build Projects Substantial number of water/wastewater projects

City of Houstons Northeast Water Purification Plant Expansion Northern Treatment Plant, Colorado South Florida Water Management District Town of Longboat Key, Florida Los Angeles World Airports Port of Seattle International Arrivals Facility

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Field Labeling/Evaluation of Openings - Guardian Fire Testing ...

    Field Labeling/Evaluation of Openings - Guardian Fire Testing ...

    Field Labeling / Evaluation of Openings. Reasons or possible situations for Field Labeling of Fire Doors and Frames. The fire door/frame has an existing label located in an inconspicuous location or an embossed label that has been painted over or...
  • Openness in Adoption

    Openness in Adoption

    Key Principles: Openness in Adoption. Handout #11.3 Current adoption practice favors openness in adoption, in contrast to practice in the past that favored closed/confidential adoptions. Handout #11.3 provides some of the key principles on which current practice around openness in...
  • Parallel and Perpendicular Lines y mx  b From

    Parallel and Perpendicular Lines y mx b From

    (2, 4) Let's find the equation of a line perpendicular to y = - x that passes through the point (2, 4) y = - x The slope of the first line is still -1. 1 2 4 Distribute and...
  • Chapter 5

    Chapter 5

    4.1 Define the concepts of nations, nationalism, and the nation-state. 4.2 Discuss the historical evolution of nations and nationalism. 4.3 Evaluate the positive and negative dimensions of nationalism. 3.4 Discuss the major developments in the emergence of the sovereign state.
  • On Writing Lord of the Flies It was

    On Writing Lord of the Flies It was

    Lord of the Flies. For Consideration: Golding has said that . Lord of the Flies . is "an attempt to trace the defects of society back to the defects of human nature." He acknowledges evil as a force that lurks...
  • Pass-The-Hash: Gaining Root Access to Your Network

    Pass-The-Hash: Gaining Root Access to Your Network

    Libeay32.dll is also used by Symantec's Ghost imager. Finding this file on a normal users workstation who does not have admin or incident response duties may be suspicious. ... PSHToolkit is a complete suite of PtH and hash dumping tools....
  • Fundamentals of Management 5e. - Robbins and DeCenzo

    Fundamentals of Management 5e. - Robbins and DeCenzo

    A final short-cut involves a manager's expectations. The self-fulfilling prophecy or the Pygmalion effect involves how a manager perceives others and how those persons behave in ways that are consistent with the manager's expectations. Learning is any relatively permanent change...
  • www.whsd.k12.pa.us

    www.whsd.k12.pa.us

    Pennsylvania participates in the WIDA Consortium; the Consortium provides professional development and tester training and also manages test development. ... Secretary of Education www.education.state.pa.us The Taxonomy of Assessment Anchor Content Standards Content Area Grade Level 3.