Research on Preimplantation Embryos: Ethical Imperatives D Gareth

Research on Preimplantation Embryos: Ethical Imperatives D Gareth

Research on Preimplantation Embryos: Ethical Imperatives D Gareth Jones University of Otago Background Ongoing debate and controversy Destruction of human life Same moral space as abortion

New Zealand accepts embryo destruction in IVF and PGD; appears to reject it in embryo research Background Accept 14-day limit to research? Requires agreement of Minister of Health Restrictive by default since 2007 One might have expected that anyone who permits couples to create multiple embryos for reproductive

purposes might also allow scientists to carry out research on embryos (Cole-Turner 2003) Background HART Act (2004) Establishment, prohibition, regulation Established procedures: routine clinical; no ethical approval; IVF, PGD Prohibited actions: cloned/hybrid embryos; genetic modification; embryos >14 days; commercialization;

sex selection Background Embryo research Regulated procedure (in theory) ECART approval Guidelines from ACART Ministers approval In limbo

Background Restricted by default Minister under no obligation to accept ACARTs advice Contrary to preferred position? Have recent Governments been opposed to embryo research? Consequences of current

situation Position satisfies no one Embryos destroyed in large numbers IVF, PGD (established) Wall of silence fails to satisfy those opposed to any loss of embryos IVF would not have developed without innovative research using human tissue Consequences of current

situation It is an ethical requirement that the procedures used are as effective and safe as possible, since we wrong a future child by carelessness or neglect in our reproductive conduct Green 2001 the health and well-being of children born as a result of . . . . an ART or an established procedure should be an important consideration in all decisions about that procedure HART Act 2004

Morally complicit? Consequences of current situation Day of Transfer study Cleavage stage embryo transfer (day 3) Blastocyst embryo transfer (day 5) Human reproductive research Use of embryos

Embryo transfer in IVF is established procedure Consequences of current situation Embryo research Normal development three main tissue layers and emergence of specialized tissues Tracking abnormal development, why some

embryos fail to develop, aberrant pathways leading to infertility, congenital aberrations, tumour formation Ways of improving IVF implantation rates General comments Hijacked by debate on stem cells Abortion Hampered by context of discussion Binary pro-life, pro-choice paradigm - stumbling

block Excessive emphasis on embryonic stem cells (ESCs) Overhyping potential of ESCs or dismissal of them General comments Intermingling of science and ethics Induced pluripotential stem cells (IPSCs) derived from mature cells 2006 potential exaggerated Would replace ESCs solve ethical problems

Shinya Yamanaka - promise overstated; 10 target diseases for IPSCs Problems with NZ debate over embryo research HART Act stuck in time warp Reflects stem cell centred debate in 1990s and 2000s Centrality of stem cells and ESCs Discussion around serious research into embryo

development ignored in public debate Problems with NZ debate over embryo research Is HART Act fit for purpose? Renewed debate on 14-day rule Should rule be extended to 21 or 28 days to culture embryos through implantation stages? To reveal key events of early human morphogenesis

Studies up to 13 days (Zernicka-Goetz) Debate: Warnock/Lovell-Badge Problems with NZ debate over embryo research Recent scientific developments Mitochondrial replacement therapy (3-parent embryo) In vitro screening of embryo Whole genome sequencing of embryos Connor Levy 2013

CRISPR gene editing Need for education on developments with major repercussions for the ARTs Problems with NZ debate over embryo research Words/labels Intimidating social connotations of research, genetic modification, selection, gene editing,

designer babies etc Consider hypothetical future: possible choice of PGD over gene-editing technology; directions will still need to be charted Ongoing conceptual blocks Consensus on moral status of embryo is not feasible in pluralist societies Acceptance of compromise

Diversity of religious views God and the Embryo, 2003 Embryo research is not morally indifferent action Ongoing conceptual blocks A time-limit on research is a public policy tool to carve out a space for scientific inquiry and also show respect for diverse views on legitimacy of

this research Success of 14-day rule: legally enforceable stopping point for research Satisfies neither extreme Balance between enabling research and maintaining public trust Concluding comments HART Act is cautious; some merit in this Arena for informed public debate lacking

Debate needed if we want the public to have confidence in regulation of science Scientific and clinical communities need to know their input is respected and taken into account in decision-making

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Cyber Terrorism Adrian Suarez Gabriel Otero Fraz Bokhari

    Cyber Terrorism Adrian Suarez Gabriel Otero Fraz Bokhari

    "the use of computer network tools to shut down critical national infrastructures (e.g., energy, transportation, government operations) or to coerce or intimidate a government or civilian population." William Tafoya, Professor of Criminal Justice at the Henry C. Lee College of...
  • New Legislation Chapter 12 pp. 407-463

    New Legislation Chapter 12 pp. 407-463

    p. 75. Landscaper - sells equipment and design (consulting) Does not sell the trees, shrubs, flowers it recommends. Invoices separately. One set of books - single trade or business . 2,000,000. 250,000. Total Gross . Receipts. Consulting . Gross Receipts...
  • Sistem Pencarian Dan Capaian Dokumen - .: Ftsm

    Sistem Pencarian Dan Capaian Dokumen - .: Ftsm

    About 144,000 English words. Nouns, adjectives, verbs, and adverbs grouped into about 109,000 synonym sets called synsets. Penggunaan WordNet dalam perkembangan kueri Add synonyms in the same synset. Add hyponyms to add specialized terms. Add hypernyms to generalize a query....
  • The Watson's Go to Birmingham - Moore Public Schools

    The Watson's Go to Birmingham - Moore Public Schools

    The Watson's Go to Birmingham. Chapters 1-4. Chapter 1 Writing Time . ... Hambone scared Momma into thinking there were no black people in Michigan. Why would this bother Momma? ... How did Kenny feel when Rufus got mad at...
  • The Challenge: To Create More Value in All Negotiations

    The Challenge: To Create More Value in All Negotiations

    need MicrosoftWord FONTS "Showcard Gothic," "Ravie," "Chiller" and "Verdana" Master* Excellence part one (of 3) introduction to excellence.


    TRANONT - Change Life! A Financial Education and Services Company. Mission: Change the world's economy, one household at a time. Vision: We offer individuals world class financial education and training, financial management tools, digital protection and best in class retail...
  • Mental Health and Wellbeing Thursday 3rd December 2015

    Mental Health and Wellbeing Thursday 3rd December 2015

    Dörte Bemme is a PhD candidate at McGill University. Her research involves multi-sited fieldwork within the institutional assemblage of Global Mental Health, investigating how GMH re-configures the knowledges and practices that define what a 'mental health' problem is and how...
  • Financial Performance

    Financial Performance

    Received "unmodified" opinion , the most favorable, from external/ independent auditors (Moss Adams LLP). Received "unmodified" opinion from . Pricewaterhouse. Coopers, LLP. for the "Education Trust of Alaska".