The Nuts and Bolts of Redundancy Rob Smith

The Nuts and Bolts of Redundancy Rob Smith

The Nuts and Bolts of Redundancy Rob Smith 8 July 2009 Topics for Discussion Redundancy selection criteria and age discrimination. Collective Consultation & The Duty to Inform and consult.

Enhanced Redundancy Pay. Statutory Lay off and unlawful deduction from wages. Changes to terms and conditions Redundancy in a Recession Financial crisis Multiple business failures Mass redundancies a reality but Obligation to follow a

fair procedure Definition of Redundancy Section 139(1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 - cessation of the business or diminution of need for employees to carry out work of a particular kind. Murray v- Foyle Meats focus on whether work has diminished and if so whether dismissal is attributable to that fall.

Redundancy Selection S.98(4) test of reasonableness focus on: Identifying the pool The criteria for selection

Applying the criteria Consultation Alternative employment The Pool for Selection ET have to determine whether definition of pool is within the range of responses. Thomas & Betts Manufacturing v Harding employer has applied their mind to issue and acted from genuine motives. Practical difficulties of challenging whether too

wide or too narrow. The Selection Procedure Not rocket science best if criteria are as objective as possible. If so ET should not subject to close scrutiny. Common criteria include: - Performance skill & knowledge - Absence record - Disciplinary record - Length of service

Contractual Selection Procedures Failure to agree selection criteria not necessarily unfair. But where contractual scheme in place, employer will be expected to stick to it.

Central question therefore whether scheme is contractual. Has it been incorporated and is it apt for incorporation c.f. selection issues and entitlement to enhanced redundancy pay.

Kaur v- MG Rover & Albion Automotive v- Walker & Ors. Applying the Selection Criteria Williams v- Compare Maxam Ltd ET strictly limited not to minutely scrutinise or substitute its decision. Must ensure method not inherently unfair and applied fairly. Managers unlikely to attend ET to explain scores

Looking for fundamental flaws in the overall process not a re-scoring exercise. Consultation Specific obligations in mass redundancies under s.188 TULR(C)A 1992. Obligation to follow the statutory 3 step procedure up to 6 April. There after ACAS code of Practice on redundancy. Mugford -v- Midland Bank EAT guidance on obligations re individual consultation.

Consultation Warning that individual at risk Confirmation of basis for selection Opportunity for employee to comment on assessment Consideration of alternative employment Opportunity to appeal Consultation cont Timing consultation must not be too late in the

process Collective consultation Does not remove obligation to consult individual but may limit scope Right to be accompanied remains Appeal no longer statutory right but dangerous not to allow and could cure previous unfairness. Alternative Employment Consideration of alternative employment is an important part of a fair procedure

Size and resources of the employer relevant Employer expected to take reasonable steps not simply to notify but give additional information Suitability of Alternative Employment S.141 Unreasonable refusal of suitable alternative employment Test of unreasonableness involves detailed consideration of employees

personal circumstances. Hudson vGeorge Harrison Trial Periods mandatory 4 week trial Compensation & Polkey Repeal of s98A ERA automatic unfair dismissal for failure to follow 3 steps Return of Polkey v- Dayton Services Procedural unfairness will render dismissal unfair but ET may reduce compensation to reflect chance of dismissal at later date Not applicable where the unfairness is

substantive rather than simply procedural Conclusion Difficult claims to pursue. Need for a realistic approach but a thorough examination of the process adopted. As recession continues union representation more important than ever to mitigate redundancies and

ensure rights protected whilst still within the workplace.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Chapter 1 Health Career Clusters - PC\|MAC

    Chapter 1 Health Career Clusters - PC\|MAC

    Chapter 1 Health Care Career Clusters Health Care Science Technology
  • Southwestern US seasonal precipitation and fire frequency from

    Southwestern US seasonal precipitation and fire frequency from

    *May also add season climate patterns for back to back fire years, an analysis that focuses on role of the monsoon more specifically, and/or a quick and dirt regression using climate and prior fire to predict DEM series Correlations between...
  • Regional Haze Rule

    Regional Haze Rule

    SAGO. JOSH. PORE. SAGA. DOME. KAIS. LAVO. ... Arial Times New Roman Symbol Default Design Microsoft Excel Chart Microsoft Office Excel Chart Microsoft Photo Editor 3.0 Photo REGIONAL HAZE Progress Report CALIFORNIA CLASS 1 AREAS OVERVIEW BASIC REQUIREMENTS MONITOR DATA...
  • How Do We Classify Matter?

    How Do We Classify Matter?

    physical ways TO SEPARATE MIXTURES: NOTCHEMICALLY SEPARATED BY DOING CHEMICAL REACTIONS BREAKING ELECTRON BONDS. SIFTING (2 different-sized solids) MAGNETICS. FILTRATION (solid from a liquid) EVAPORATION (solute from a solvent
  • Responding to Open-Ended Text Dependent Questions

    Responding to Open-Ended Text Dependent Questions

    Once he reaches the island, he goes to sleep and later realizes "where there are pistol shots, there are men. Where there are men, there is food" (16). His ability to think through this situation and make it to land...
  • Literary Terms for the Grad Exam - PC\|MAC

    Literary Terms for the Grad Exam - PC\|MAC

    Dynamic Characters (Shrek)- grow and change throughout the story. Static Characters (Pinocchio)- stay the same. Character. ... Provides info on plot, background, setting, and characters. Ex. Basil Exposition from . Austin Powers. Rising Action.
  • Chapter 1

    Chapter 1

    Chapter 1 Introduction to Psychology and Research Methods Psychology Science of behavior and mental processes Goal is to describe, understand, predict and control behavior History of Psychology Began as a science in 1879 Wundt ("the father of psychology") built the...
  • Todays Objectives  TSW be able to recognize and

    Todays Objectives TSW be able to recognize and

    Directional Orientation Anterior vs. Posterior Dorsal vs. Ventral Medial vs. Lateral Distal vs. Proximal Inferior vs. Superior Cephalic vs. Caudal Aboral vs. Oral Body Plans Acoelomate Pseudocoelomate Eucoelomate Tissue Layer Body Plans Diploblastic - ectoderm and gastroderm separated by mesoglea...