The Story of Sally Clark - National University of Singapore

The Story of Sally Clark - National University of Singapore

The Story of Sally Clark Group 2 - Jing Kai (Presenter), Nabilah, Soon Guan Reading Sally Clark (5 February 2017). Retrieved 21 March 2017, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Clark The statement by Professor Dawidon: SALLY CLARK APPEAL. Retrieved

from http://www.statslab.cam.ac.uk/~apd/SallyClark_report.doc Overview Background Information Conviction for Murder Analysis of Statistical Evidence Aftermath Conclusion Background Information Born an only child in Wiltshire,

South West England) Married solicitor Steve Clark (1990) Moved to Cheshire, North West England in order to practice law with her husband (1994) Conviction for Murder Two separate incidences where Sally Clarks baby passed away due to unknown causes (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, SIDS) Sally Clark was found alone at home on both occasions

No evidence to prove or disprove her involvement Sally Clark was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment on 9th November, 1999 The Antagonists Dr Alan Williams Withheld microbiology test

results for second baby Tests showed the bacterium Staphylococcus aureus in multiple sites of the baby Baby could have died due to health concerns! The Antagonists

Bayes analysis: 1 in 73 million chance (1/8543) x (1/8543) of two children from an affluent family suffering cot death Professor Sir Roy Meadow

Conclusion that since this probability is very low, the probability of murder is very high Analysis of Statistical Evidence 1) Assumption of independence Flaws in calculation: Lurking variables: Gender, genetic or environmental factors

Chances of a second death increases by 5-10 fold after the first Uncertainty with probability of double cot death most likely understated Analysis of Statistical Evidence

2) Relevance of data: Fallacious logic Probability of double cot death (Prosecutors fallacy)

Double cot murder is a less likely phenomenon Relative likelihood should be used Probably of innocence! Relative likelihood P (2 SIDS deaths in a

family) = 1 in 5 million P (2 murdered babies in a family) = 1 in 15 million P (2 SIDS deaths in a family) : P (2 murdered babies in a family) =3:1 Aftermath

Unearthing of microbiological tests by Sally Clarks husband Along with the case for flawed statistical evidence, Sally Clark was acquitted in January 2003 Review of hundreds other cases 3 similar cases overturned Aftermath Roy Meadow was struck off the medical register in 2005 for serious professional misconduct but subsequently reinstated after appeal Dr Alan Williams was banned from Home Office pathology work and coroners' cases for three years Sally Clark diagnosed with psychiatric problems associated with posttraumatic disorder and alcohol dependency syndrome Passed away on

16th March 2007 due to acute alcohol intoxication "Throughout my review, I was horrified by the shoddy fashion in which these cases were evaluated. It was clear that sound medical principles were abandoned in favour of over-simplification, over-interpretation, exclusion of relevant data and, in several instances, the imagining of non-existent findings." Dr Sam Gulino, forensic pathologist for the State of Florida, USA. Conclusion Logical and accurate use of statistical information with

explanations required Data needs to be precise and context-specific Failure to make appropriate inferences from statistics can result in fatal consequences Thank You!

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Sin título de diapositiva - Zona CLIL

    Sin título de diapositiva - Zona CLIL

    Plenty of love Tons of kisses Hope some day To be your Mrs. Postman, postman, do your duty Take this to my loving beauty. Postman, postman, do not tarry take this to the one I'll marry Oh, The Grand Old...
  • Caption Search for Bioscience Search Interfaces Marti Hearst,

    Caption Search for Bioscience Search Interfaces Marti Hearst,

    UC Berkeley Biotext Project UC Berkeley Biotext Project * 3/2/98 Slide by James Landay 3/2/98 Slide by James Landay Design Prototype Evaluate 3/2/98 Slide by James Landay Telebears example Telebears example: Task 4: Adding a course Slide adapted from James...
  • Glencoe Geometry - Dolfanescobar's Weblog

    Glencoe Geometry - Dolfanescobar's Weblog

    A. 214.2 m2 B. 221.0 m2 C. 233.4 m2 D. 247.5 m2 Find the surface area of the cone. A. 80 ft2 B. 200 ft2 C. 240 ft2 D. 260 ft2 Find the surface area of a square pyramid with...
  • 7th Grade Science State Assessment Review - Ms. Gorman's Class

    7th Grade Science State Assessment Review - Ms. Gorman's Class

    (S4.B1.1)-- The student identifies properties of the solid earth, the oceans and fresh water, and the atmosphere. ... you can come up with a mnemonic device. One example, My Very Earnest Mother Just Served Us Nuts, is a mnemonic device...
  • Laws of Indices - WordPress.com

    Laws of Indices - WordPress.com

    Laws of Indices OCR Module 8 What are Indices? Indices provide a way of writing numbers in a more convenient form Indices is the plural of Index An Index is often referred to as a power For example Combining numbers...
  • Therac-25 Case - OpenStax CNX

    Therac-25 Case - OpenStax CNX

    A patient has complained that he has received a radiation overdose during a treatment session caused by the malfunctioning of the Therac-25 unit. Construct . an argument for . or against the continued . operation of the therac-25 units while...
  • Disruption-Oriented Systems Engineering with Object-Process Methodology: Cyber-Physical Perceptional

    Disruption-Oriented Systems Engineering with Object-Process Methodology: Cyber-Physical Perceptional

    Nominalism is the anchor for disruption: if nothing is in-order - there's nothing to disrupt. ... Define knowledge base. Integrate into system decisions, actions, reactions, and interactions. Capture implications of incoherent conceptions .
  • Classification of Living Organisms - Ms. Trimble's Website

    Classification of Living Organisms - Ms. Trimble's Website

    Monera. Protista. Fungi. Plantae. ... Example - land, water or air. Jan Swammerdam (1637-1680) A Dutch naturalist and microscopist; was among the first to recognize cells in animals and view red blood cells. ... Classification of Living Organisms