What We Believe and Teach

What We Believe and Teach

Philosophical Theology 1 (TH5) Philosophy of Human Nature Ross Arnold, Summer 2014 Lakeside institute of Theology Philosophical Theology 1 (TH5) Aug. 15 Intro to Philosophical Theology; Logic Aug. 22 Truth & Epistemology Aug. 29 Metaphysics Sept. 5 No Class Sept. 12 Philosophy of Religion Sept. 19 Philosophy of Science; Human Nature; Philosophy of Politics Sept. 26 Ethics: What is Right?; Aesthetics: What is Beautiful? October 3 Philosophy of Human Nature; Final Exam What is philosophy? Literally, it is a love of wisdom phileo is Greek for love, sophos means wisdom. Philosophy is the critical examination of our

foundational beliefs concerning the nature of reality, knowledge and truth; and our moral and social values. Philosophy is the means and process by which we examine our lives and the meaning in our lives. Philosophy is the attempt to think rationally and critically about lifes most important questions in order to obtain knowledge and wisdom about them. Philosophy of Human Nature What am I? Perhaps the most basic questions regarding human nature are: What makes us human? and What gives each of us our distinct personalities? Or, What makes me, ME? What makes me human, and what makes me distinct from other humans?

Mind-Body Dualism proposes that people have two distinct aspects or parts: their physical bodies; and their immaterial, non-physical souls. Physicalism proposes that everything including the human consciousness can be fully described in terms of physics and physical processes. (based on philosophical materialism) Philosophy of Human Nature Mind-Body Dualism Descartes argued for mind-body dualism, saying: Mind and body have very different and distinct properties. The body is divisible while the mind is indivisible. The activity of the mind is private, while the activities of body

are observable and so public. Argument from Subjectivity The human mind has a sense of subjectivity, and can perceive subjectivity in other cognitive creatures, so that we can imagine being in the place of other cognitive creatures, but never of non-cognitive objects. This suggests the mind is fundamentally more than physical. Argument Humans from Qualia constantly are perceiving qualia phenomenal qualities of things in all perceptual experiences, but no physicalist description of the brain can account for this aspect of perceptual experience.

Philosophy of Human Nature Mind-Body Dualism Argument from Intentionality The recognition that mental states refer to things outside themselves in a way that requires no sense of physical relationship we simply think about things in meaningful ways which no merely physical object could ever do. Criticisms Problem of Mind-Dualism of Casual Overdetermination says that the entire chain of perceptual experience involves concrete objects and processes so how is the soul involved? The Interaction Problem says that for the soul to be separate from and yet causally interact with the physical body it would have to create energy, but where would

such energy come from? (The 2nd law of thermodynamics says energy cannot be either created or destroyed.) Philosophy of Human Nature Physicalism Philosophical Behaviorism The insistence that we are only physical beings, and that functions and qualities normally associated with the mind are in fact simply behaviors or tendencies to behave in certain ways. Criticisms of Philosophical Behaviorism Some thoughts, feelings and desires are never expressed as behaviors. In fact, some behaviors may be contrary to

feelings. Other thoughts (such as abstracts) have no possible manifestation in behavior. This denies the subjective that is, interior and hidden first-person aspects of the mind that go beyond behavior. Philosophy of Human Nature Physicalism Strict Identity Theory Mental states are synonymous with brain states; sensations, beliefs, awareness are nothing more than chemical events and processes within the brain. Criticisms This of Strict Identity Theory

theory insists that brain states and mental states are the same, but this cannot be true there are mental states which cannot be directly equated to concrete events, locations, shapes or other physical criteria. There is not hard evidence to support that ALL mental activity such as subjective awareness, perception of qualia, intentionality is physically specific within the brain. (Eliminativists insist that science will eventually show this connection) Philosophy of Human Nature Physicalism Functionalism Focuses not on what the brain is, but on what it does. In effect, the human mind is simply a very sophisticated computing device, so that there will (so they say) someday be Artificial Intelligence systems that will also be able to demonstrate beliefs, intentions and self-awareness. Criticisms Critics

of Functionalism insist that reduction of mental states to causal or computational operations within our brain does not adequately account for the qualitative facts of human mental life especially the perception and evaluation of qualia such as colors, flavors, smells, tastes, etc. (Searle and his property dualism, which regards mental states as properties of the brain.) Philosophy of Human Nature Personal Identity What makes a person distinct from all other persons? What constitutes personal identity? And what happens if a person significantly changes are they still the same person? Is

a changed person still the same person if He retains the continuity of his memories? He has the same body and same relevant physical characteristics? (motivated by a materialistic worldview) He has the same brain? He has the same soul? (the resurrection question) Or, perhaps He has the same character, as reflected in his motivations. (a new creation) Philosophy of Human Nature Free Will Are we free agents? Are we able to make our own choices, to do good or bad, to act or refrain from acting as we wish, and so to be held morally responsible?

What is the relationship between human freedom and determinism (the materialistic idea that all things must act according to unchangeable natural laws)? Compatibilism says that human freedom and determinism are logically consistent. Incompatibilism says that human freedom and responsibility are NOT compatible with determinism. Philosophy of Human Nature Incompatibilism Hard determinism accepts the consequent argument our acts are the consequences of the laws of nature and the past, and so we are not free or morally responsible for our actions.

Libertarianism the idea that humans have the power of contrary choice, or the ability to do otherwise, as a necessary requirement for moral responsibility. (most consistent with orthodox Christianity) The libertarians dilemma is a false argument that a persons actions must either be determined, or else happen by a chance occurrence of factors, and so either way are not under that persons control. This is false because it fails to realize factors may exist that influence a persons actions without requiring them, and so still allow free choice so Philosophy of Human Nature Compatibilism Compatibilism insists that human actions can be determined in some ways, without this constituting a threat to human freedom and moral responsibility.

When we speak of free action, all we mean is that a person is able to do what he wants to do, and that what the person does (as long as not coerced or constrained) is what they wanted to do. Freedom is the ability to act according to ones desires and intentions, and this is compatible with determinism, as our choices occur within the parameters of natural law, and so we are morally responsible for our actions.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Physical Science Chapter 4 - Central Lyon

    Physical Science Chapter 4 - Central Lyon

    Developed a theory to explain why the elements in a compound always behave in the same way. Main Points. 1) All elements are composed of atoms. 2) All atoms of the same element have the same mass, and atoms of...
  • Oceanographic Common Search Interface OCSI

    Oceanographic Common Search Interface OCSI

    Portal Working Group @ JPL. 07/17/2012. ESIP Summer Meeting 2012. Small group of individuals working on portals all over JPL. Goal: Share knowledge and experience on portal projects worked on and eventually pool together reusable work for future reference.
  • The ATCA: 20 years young

    The ATCA: 20 years young

    Operations Philip Edwards Head of Science Operations 28 October 2008 Operations: Themes, Streams and Projects Structure End of an era… Science Operations Telescope Operations and Science Services TAC met; schedules for 2008OCTS out; ATS Project Submitted Joint TOSS/SCA/CI discussions on...
  • Barrier Breakers: Advocacy, Linking and Letting Go

    Barrier Breakers: Advocacy, Linking and Letting Go

    Barrier Breakers: Advocacy, Linking, & Letting Go Misty Miller, MSW, CIRS Traci Byrd, CIRS 2-1-1 Texas/United Way of Greater Houston AIRS Annual Training & Education Conference Wednesday, May 26, 2010
  • MiniCon and Adaptive Re-Optimization

    MiniCon and Adaptive Re-Optimization

    Problems here: Don't know when join buffers vs. "discards" tuples Eddy Pros and Cons Mechanism for adaptively re-routing queries Makes optimizer's task simpler Can do nearly as well as well-optimized plan in some cases Handles variable costs, variable selectivities But...


    Married Anne Hathaway and had 3 Children. Susanna. Hamnet and Judith. Wrote almost 40 plays (comedies, histories, tragedies) ... —14-line poem of iambic pentameter with rhyme scheme . ababcdcdefefgg "To be, or not to be: that is the question". ......
  • UV Spectroscopy

    UV Spectroscopy

    Microwave. Visible. UV Spectroscopy. Introduction. The Spectroscopic Process. In UV spectroscopy, the sample is irradiated with the broad spectrum of the UV radiation. If a particular electronic transition matches the energy of a certain band of UV, it will be...
  • Hippocrates = 460370BC 4 humours Greek doctor Importance

    Hippocrates = 460370BC 4 humours Greek doctor Importance

    Plotted cases of cholera and identified the source to be the Broad Street pump- cesspit. ... Due to the cholera epidemics and the Great Stink of 1858, was contracted to build sewers ... Lister had used penicillin in the 19th...